! ["]
# $ $ # %
[&] '
# % ()* ()* (²
[) () '
' %
[+],
&()- ./ 0- 10→&()0- 1)0"
2 333$ 4
333$ ,
&()- &()0→5()0- 6)R &
7 333$ % ,
6)R- 50- 10→6 1)0 +
0
[6$.] 3
[8$"+] % 33$ 333
# 9 ["6] '%
' :$$ VE;
:/$ VE;
! ["& "+],
:$=9"$+:9$P:/
$:/ 6
, :$P $
VE;)H6 9$ $ ;VE
< % ["+]
'
7 ; :7 VE;
8 UDGX MH SULND]DQ NLQHWL NL PRGHO RNVLGDFLMH SLULWD )H6 X VXVSHQ]LML SRPRþX
EDNWHULMH $FLGLWKLREDFLOOXV IHUURR[LGDQV X HUOHQPDMHULPD X] PXþNDQMH .RQFHQ WUDFLMH þHOLMD EDNWHULMD DGVRUERYDQLK QD HVWLFH SLULWD L VORERGQR VXVSHQGRYDQLK þHOLMD X OXçQRP UDVWYRUX VX X UDYQRWHçL VDJODVQR /DQJPXLURYRM DGVRUSFLRQRM L]RWHUPL 6SHFLIL QD EU]LQD UDVWD DGVRUERYDQLK þHOLMD µ$ G² MH RGUHH
QD L] SURPHQH NRQFHQWUDFLMH JYRçD X OXçQRP UDVWYRUX 0RGHO SRND]XMH GREUR VODJDQMH VD HNVSHULPHQWDOQLP SRGDFLPD SURPHQH NRQFHQWUDFLMH L]OXçHQRJ JYRçD L VORERGQH ELRPDVH X WRNX ELRRNVLGDFLMH SLULWD X VXVSHQ]LML
!" #
$%& ""'
( )& ) & * ++ ( ) ,& - ++
X WRNX ELRRNVLGDFLMH SLULWD X VXVSHQ]LML PRJX VH RSLVDWL VOHGHþLP GLIHUHQFLMDOQLP MHGD LQDPD[]
G)H7
GW =<;6$ +II< ;6 / ⋅
G;7
GW
G;7
GW = µ$;$( ²α)Θ
+I<;6 /
<;$V
JGH MH I ²PDVHQL XGHR JYRçD X SLULWX J)HJ)H6 L <;6$
L <;6/ NRHILFLMHQWL SULQRVD DGVRUERYDQH L VORERGQR VXV
SHQGRYDQH ELRPDVH X RGQRVX QD L]OXçHQR JYRçH PJVEJ)H Dµ$²VSHFLIL QD EU]LQD UDVWD DGVRUERYDQH
ELRPDVH G² 6PDQMHQMH SRYUåLQH HVWLFD XVOHG EDNWH ULMVNRJ GHMVWYD NRULJXMH VH PQRçHQMHP VD ²α SUL HPXαSUHGVWDYOMD RGQRV XNXSQR L]OXçHQRJ L SR HWQRJ VDGUçDMD JYRçD X SLULWX )H7)H 5DVW ELRPDVH ]DYLVL L
RG SULVWXSD QH VORERGQH SRYUåLQH HVWLFD SLULWD Θ=;$P² ;$
;$P 3URPHQD NRQFHQWUDFLMH ELRPDVH X OXçQRP
UDVWYRUX VDJODVQD MH EU]LQL OXçHQMD JYRçD [] RGQRVQR
;/=285T / 2
= T2
<6/ G)HGW7
JGH MH T2²VSHFLIL QD EU]LQD SRWURåQMH NLVHRQLND EDN WHULMD PJ2PJVEG[]L <26/ ²NRHILFLMHQW SR
WURåQMH NLVHRQLND X OXçQRP UDVWYRUX X RGQRVX QD L]OXçHQR JYRçH
.RHILFLMHQW SULQRVD DGVRUERYDQH ELRPDVH X RGQR VX QD L]OXçHQR JYRçH <;6$ = PJVEJ)H L]UD XQD
YD VH OLQHDUL]DFLMRP VOHGHþH MHGQD LQH[]
<;6$ =(;7²;7)9 ²α:I<;6 /
α:
JGH MH :²SR HWQD PDVD HVWLFD SLULWD J L 9 ²]DSUH
PLQD VXVSHQ]LMH GP $NWXHOQD L SR HWQD NRQFHQ WUDFLMD XNXSQH ELRPDVH ;7 ;74 SUHGVWDYOMD ]ELU VORERGQR VXVSHQGRYDQH L]UD XQDWH SUHNR EU]LQH SRWUR åQMH NLVHRQLND L DGVRUERYDQH ELRPDVH NRMD VH L]UD XQD YD SRPRþX VOHGHþH MHGQD LQH
;$=.$;+$P. ;/: $;/9 ( ²α)
&LOM RYRJ UDGD MH UD]YRM PDWHPDWL NRJ PRGHOD NRML RSLVXMH OXçHQMH SLULWD SRPRþX EDNWHULMH X HUOHQPDMHULPD X] PXþNDQMH NDR L SURFH QD XWLFDMD VORERGQR VXVSHQGRYDQLK L DGVRUERYDQLK þHOL MD QD ELRSURFHV
(NVSHULPHQWL VX L]YHGHQL VD EDNWHULMRP % L] ]ELU NH PLNURRUJDQL]DPD &HQWUD ]D KHPLMX ,+70 %HRJUDG %DNWHULMVND RNVLGDFLMD SLULWD SURX DYDQD MH X HUOHQPDMHUL
PD RGQRV UDGQH L ]DSUHPLQH HUOHQPDMHUD FP X] PXþNDQMH SUH QLN URWDFLMH FP EU]LQD URWDFLMH V² 8 HNVSHULPHQWX MH NRULåþHQ LQRNXOXP L] VUHGQMH HN VSRQHQFLMDOQH ID]H GDQD VWDU X NROL LQL RG YY RG UDGQH ]DSUHPLQH ELRUHDNWRUD 5DGQD WHPSHUDWXUD X VYLP LVSLWLYDQMLPD MH RGUçDYDQD QD R&
8 UDGX MH NRULåþHQ NRQFHQWUDW SLULWD NRML VDGUçL JYRçD PDVHQL XGHR JYRçD X SLULWX I J)HJ)H6 D HVWLFD SLULWD MH PDQMH RG
PP .RQFHQWUDW SLULWD VH VWHULOLåH DVD QD R& =D SURFHV ELROXçHQMD JYRçD VWHULOQL SUDK NRQFHQWUDWD SLULWD VH GRGDMH JGP X DVHSWL QLP XVORYLPD X WH QX SRG ORJX . VOHGHþHJ VDVWDYD JGP 1+62² .+32
² 0J62+2 ² .&O ² L &D12²
! "
8NXSQR UDVWYRUQR JYRçH MH RGUHLYDQR SODPH QRP DWRPVNRP DSVRUSFLRQRP VSHNWURIRWRPHWULMRP 3<( 81,&$0 $$6 ² 3KLOOLSV
# !$
%U]LQD SRWURåQMH NLVHRQLND X OXçQRP UDVWYRUX RGUH LYDQD MH L] QDJLED SUDYROLQLMVNRJ GHOD ]DYLVQRVWL QRUPD OL]RYDQH NRQFHQWUDFLMH NLVHRQLND RG YUHPHQD 5HODWLYQD NRQFHQWUDFLMD NLVHRQLND X SRGOR]L PHUHQD MH NLVHRQL
QRP HOHNWURGRP +$11$ +,
# # ! #
=D RGUHLYDQMH RGQRVD DGVRUERYQH L VORERGQR VXVSHQGRYDQH ELRPDVH þHOLMD L]GYRMHQ MH OXçQL UDVWYRU L] ELRRNVLGDFLMH SLULWD X EDUERWDçQRM NRORQL SRVOH GDQD VD SR]QDWRP NRQFHQWUDFLMRP ELRPDVH RGUHHQD PHWR GRP VXåHQMD ²[] 5D]OL LWLP RGQRVLPD OXçQRJ UDVWYR UD L SRGORJH . GRGDYDQ MH SLULW ZY 1DNRQ PXþNDQMD K SUH QLN URWDFLMH FP EU]LQD URWDFLMH V² VXVSHQ]LMDPD MH RGUHLYDQD EU]LQD SRWURåQMH NLVH RQLND X OXçQRP UDVWYRUX 5D]OLND NRQFHQWUDFLMD ELRPDVH L]UD XQDWLK L] EU]LQD SRWURåQMH NLVHRQLND SUHNR VSHFLIL QH EU]LQH SRWURåQMH NLVHRQLND[] SUH L SRVOH PXþND QMD VD SLULWRP RGJRYDUD NRQFHQWUDFLML ELRPDVH NRMD MH DGKHURYDQD QD HVWLFH SLULWD 3UHWSRVWDYOMHQR MH GD VH SRVOH PXþNDQMD RG VDWD SRVWLçH UDYQRWHçD L]PHX DG KHURYDQH L ELRPDVH X OXçQRP UDVWYRUX NDR L GD MH EURM þHOLMD DGKHURYDQLK QD ]LG HUOHQPDMHUD ]DQHPDUOMLY[] %& &'
=DYLVQRVW DGVRUERYDQH L VORERGQR VXVSHQGRYDQH ELRPDVH X WRNX ELRRNVLGDFLMH SLULWD X HUOHQPDMHULPD X] PXþNDQMH RSLVDQD MH /DQJPXLURYRP DGVRUSFLRQRP UDY QRWHçQRP L]RWHUPRP VOLND 9UHGQRVWL PDNVLPDOQRJ DGVRUSFLRQRJ NDSDFLWHWD ;$P PJVEJ)H6 L
NRQVWDQWH DGVRUSFLMH .$ GPPJVE L]UD XQDWH
VX SRVOH OLQHDUL]DFLMH MHGQD LQH
1D RVQRYX MHGQD LQD L L]UD XQDWH VX YUHGQRVWL NRQFHQWUDFLMH XNXSQR UDVWYRUHQRJ JYRçD L NRQFHQWUDFL MH ELRPDVH X OXçQRP UDVWYRUX NRMH SRND]XMX GREUR VOD JDQMH VD HNVSHULPHQWDOQLP YUHGQRVWLPD GRELMHQLP X
'6 6$9,ý L VDU 2.6,'$&,-$ 3,5,7$ 3202ý8 %$.7(5,-( +HP LQG
# (' 4 > >
< + 0 0 > 2%-A &' *
* # =' 4+ 0 0 1 > 2 ,1 & ?
#D D'
= 3
7 = 0
0 + #µ 2
,A ' E+E
0 0 # $' 4+ * 0 0 0 #> '
%= 9&# [,-]'
%'&()
< # A' ,$, &# (' !
* 0 # $' 9 [$ A =] * + * ! 0#': + # (' F 0 0 0#':[,-] 0#': + +
+[$]
4+ #%$ &' +
0#': #%,A &'
# 0 0' * + 7 #, ' 0#': #, '
!
" # $%/&%) '
())&*))+ , $'(-(( ²- '" +
. / H V NRQ FHQWUDFLMD ELRPDVH X OXçQRP UDVWYRUX R 0RGHO ² SXQH OLQLMH ,V SUHNLGDQD OLQLMD ² NRQFHQWUDFLMD XNXSQH ELRPDVH L]UD XQDWH SUHPD PRGHOX
)LJXUH 0RGHO RIS\ULWH ELRR[LGDWLRQ LQ (UOHQPD\HU IODVNV 9/9) VKDNHQ RQ D URWDWLRQDO VKDNHU IUHTXHQF\
V² DQG RUELW GLDPHWHU FP ([SHULPHQW WRWDO GLVVROYHG LURQ V DQG ELRPDVV FRQFHQWUDWLRQ LQ WKH FXOWXUH PHGLXP R 0RGHO IXOO OLQHV DQG WRWDO ELRPDVV FRQFHQWUDWLRQ FDOFXODWHG XVLQJ WKH PRGHO HTXDWLRQ GRWWHG OLQH
6OLND (NVSHULPHQWDOQH V L L]UD XQDWH OLQLMH YUHGQRVWL NRQ FHQWUDFLMH XNXSQRJ JYRçD SUHPD PRGHOX ]D UD]OL LWH YUHGQRVWL VSHFLIL QH EU]LQH PLNUREQRJ UDVWD X HUOHQPDMHUX 9/9) X] PXþNDQMH Y V² U FP
)LJXUH &RPSDULVRQ RIWKH H[SHULPHQWDO V DQG FDOFXODWHG OL QHV YDOXHV RI WKH WRWDO LURQ FRQFHQWUDWLRQ IRU GLIIHUHQW VSHFLILF PLFURELDO JURZWK UDWHV IRU S\ULWH ELRR[LGDWLRQ LQ (UOHQPD\HU IODVNV 9/9) VKDNHQ RQ D URWDWLRQDO VKDNHU IUHTXHQF\ V² DQG RUELW GLDPHWHU FP
'6 6$9,ý L VDU 2.6,'$&,-$ 3,5,7$ 3202ý8 %$.7(5,-( +HP LQG
! " ! #"$ %$& $ [']" ( ! ) #"$! $ IHUURR[RGDQV * ( [] ! ) # +, 8--0$"
%$" # ) $ IHUURR[RGDQV . #!
[/ ] !
) # )
( !)0*)0$% + ,- ).-/D X SLULWX
)HJGP ² NRQFHQWUDFLMD SR HWQRJ VDGUçDMD JYRçD X
SLULWX
)H7JGP ² NRQFHQWUDFLMD XNXSQRJ JYRçD X OXçQRP
UDVWYRUX
.$GPPJVE ² NRQVWDQWD DGVRUSFLMH
T2PJ2PJVEG² VSHFLIL QD EU]LQD SRWURåQMH NLVHRQLND
EDNWHULMD
9 GP ² ]DSUHPLQD VXVSHQ]LMH
:J ² SR HWQD PDVD HVWLFD SLULWD
;$PJVEGP ² NRQFHQWUDFLMD þHOLMD DGVRUERYDQLK QD HVWLFH
SLULWD
;$PPJVEJ)H6² PDNVLPDOQL DGVRUSFLRQL NDSDFLWHW
;/PJVEGP ² NRQFHQWUDFLMD VORERGQR VXVSHQGRYDQLK þHOLMD
X OXçQRP UDVWYRUX
;7PJVEGP ² NRQFHQWUDFLMD XNXSQH ELRPDVH
;7RPJVEGP² SR HWQD NRQFHQWUDFLMD XNXSQH ELRPDVH
<;6$ PJVEJ)H² NRHILFLMHQW SULQRVD DGVRUERYDQH ELRPDVH X
RGQRVX QD L]OXçHQR JYRçH
<;6/ PJVEJ)H² NRHILFLMHQW SULQRVD VORERGQR VXVSHQGRYDQH
ELRPDVH X RGQRVX QD L]OXçHQR JYRçH <26/ PJVEJ)H² NRHILFLMHQW SRWURåQMH NLVHRQLND X OXçQRP
UDVWYRUX X RGQRVX QD L]OXçHQR JYRçH
α² ² RGQRV XNXSQR L]OXçHQRJ L SR HWQRJ VDGUçDMD JYRçD X SLULWX
µ$G² ² VSHFLIL QD EU]LQD UDVWD DGVRUERYDQH ELRPDVH
Θ² ² VORERGQD SRYUåLQD HVWLFD SLULWD
/,7(5$785$
[1] 3RROH\ )' 0LQHUDO OHDFKLQJ ZLWK EDFWHULD LQ (QYL URQPHQWDO ELRWHFKQRORJ\ &) )RVWHU '$- :DVH HGV (OOLV +RUZRRG &KLFKHVWHU SS ²
[2] -RQVRQ '% .% +DOOEHUJ 5HVHDUFK 0LFURELRO
[3] 6DQG : 7 *HKUNH 5 +DOOPDQQ $6FKLSSHUV 0LQ 3UR ([W 0HW 5HY
[4] %RRQ 0 . /X\EHQ -- +HLMQHQ +\GURPHWDOOXUJ\
[5] 6FKLSSHUV 3 -R]VD $ : 6DQG $SS (QYLURQ 0LFURELRO
[6] 6FKLSSHUV $ : 6DQG $SS (QYLURQ 0LFURELRO
[7] 6DQG : 7 *HKUNH 5 +DOOPDQQ $6FKLSSHUV $SS 0L FURELRO %LRWHFKQRO
[8] $VDL 6 < .RQLVKL . <RVKLGD &KHP (QJ 6FL
[9] &UXQGZHOO ). %LRWHFKQRO %LRHQJ ² [10] .RQLVKL < < 7DVDND 6 $VDL %LRWHFKQRO %LRHQJ
[11] 1DJSDO 6 ' 'DKOVWURP 7 2OPDQ %LRWHFKQRO %LRHQJ
[12] &KDQJ <& $6 0D\HUVRQ %LRWHFKQRO %LRHQJ
[13] .RQLVKL < 6 $VDL + .DWRK %LRSURFHVV %LRHQJ
[14] 6DYLþ ' 9% 9HOMNRYLþ 0/ /D]Lþ LQ %LRKLGURPHWDOOXUJ\ DQG WKH HQYLURQPHQW WRZDUG WKH PLQLQJ RI WKH VW FHQ WXU\ 5 5DPLV $ %DOHVWHU HGV (OVHYLHU $PVWHUGDP SS
[15] 9HOMNRYLþ 9 ' 6DYLþ 0 /D]Lþ 0 9UYLþ LQ %LRKLGURPHWDO OXUJ\ DQG WKH HQYLURQPHQW WRZDUG WKH PLQLQJ RI WKH VW FHQWXU\ 5 5DPLV $ %DOHVWHU HGV (OVHYLHU $PVWHUGDP SS
[16] 6DYLþ ' 9 9HOMNRYLþ 0 /D]Lþ &RQWULEXWLRQ WR WKH TXDQWL ILFDWLRQ RI WKH $FLGLWKLREDFLOOXV IHUURR[LGDQV ELRPDVV FRQ FHQWUDWLRQ IURP WKH R[\JHQ XSWDNH UDWH WK ,QWHUQDWLRQDO %LRK\GURPHWDOOXUJ\ 6\PSRVLXP $WKHQV VHSWHPEHU 6\PSRVLXP SURFFHGLQJV RI IXOO WH[W SGI [17] %DVDUDQ $+ 2+ 7XRYLQHQ &RDO 3UHS
6800$5<
!"# $ $% &'# & &'()" !"*' ! &
+,'- " ."'"- ,' "*'"/"#(( 012 $*)" / +,'- " .3*- )#3*) 04 '# /
. ) 3"#' " - ' #**"'," /- . " " / !" *.) '3- '*) 5* *# . 3"6 #' # 5'' 5. . 73' # " . 7# " # . ,3/ " ''* . '8,# .* . * "5. " . #*"/# ''* 5* ',# µ$9 0 4 #² /- . 73' # " . 3"6
#' , '*" . ' " . 5" ""*# 3.*3* " . /6 ' #**"'," " *,'.# # # # 5* #*,**# # . . # " 5* #"3 . #*"" "** " # !" " . - *, 5* 5'' "'# /- $3, - *".3
:- 5"#*; !" • - /""7#" • !.3' 3"#'•
:'(, ; !" • )*#( • !3 ) 3"#'•
'6 6$9,ý L VDU 2.6,'$&,-$ 3,5,7$ 3202ý8 %$.7(5,-( +HP LQG