Externalismo social: mente, pensamento e linguagem

(1)

E

_XTERNALISMO _SOCIAL

_:

MENTE

,

PENSAMENTO E LINGUAGEM1

Jonas Gonçalves Coelho

2

RESUMO0HXREMHWLYRpPRVWUDUTXHDVWHVHVH[WHUQDOLVWDV´RVVLJQLÀFDGRVQmRHVWmRQDFDEHoDµH

´RVSHQVDPHQWRVQmRHVWmRQDFDEHoDµQmRLPSOLFDPQHFHVVDULDPHQWHDWHVHPDLVUDGLFDO´DPHQWH QmRHVWiQDFDEHoDµ7UDWRGHVVDTXHVWmRQRkPELWRGR([WHUQDOLVPR6RFLDOGH7\OHU%XUJHH/\QQH %DNHUDUJXPHQWDQGRTXHDLPSRUWkQFLDTXHHVVHVSHQVDGRUHVDWULEXHPjOLQJXDJHPQDVTXHVW}HV UHODWLYDVjPHQWHQmRVLJQLÀFDFRPRXPDOHLWXUDDSUHVVDGDSRGHULDVXJHULUDUHGXomRGDPHQWHj OLQJXDJHPHPXLWRPHQRVDHOLPLQDomRGDPHQWH$PLQKDFRQFOXVmRpTXHRH[WHUQDOLVPRVRFLDO OLQJXtVWLFRQmRVHFRQVWLWXLFRPRXPDHVWUDWpJLDHÀFD]GHHQIUHQWDPHQWRGRVSUREOHPDVGDQDWXUH]D GDPHQWHHGHVXDUHODomRFRPRFRUSR

PALAVRAS-CHAVE ([WHUQDOLVPR 6RFLDO /\QQH %DNHU 7\OHU %XUJH 0HQWH 3HQVDPHQWR

Linguagem.

1 INTRODUÇÃO

0HXREMHWLYRQRSUHVHQWHDUWLJRpPRVWUDUTXHDVWHVHVH[WHUQDOLVWDV´RV VLJQLÀFDGRVQmRHVWmRQDFDEHoDµH´RVSHQVDPHQWRVQmRHVWmRQDFDEHoDµQmR LPSOLFDP QHFHVVDULDPHQWH D WHVH PDLV UDGLFDO ´D PHQWH QmR HVWi QD FDEHoDµ 7DOLPSOLFDomRDPHXYHULPSOtFLWDQDLQWHUSUHWDomRGRH[WHUQDOLVPROLQJXtVWLFR IXQFLRQDFRPRXPDHVWUDWpJLDGHHQIUHQWDPHQWRGRVSUREOHPDVGDQDWXUH]DGD PHQWHHGHVXDUHODomRFRPRFRUSR7UDWDUHLGHVVDTXHVWmRQRkPELWRGHXP WLSR SDUWLFXODU GH H[WHUQDOLVPR DTXHOH TXH D ÀOyVRID /\QQH %DNHU FKDPD GH

_{2SUHVHQWHDUWLJRIRLSURGX]LGRDSDUWLUGHSHVTXLVDUHDOL]DGDGXUDQWHHVWiJLRGH3yV'RXWRUDGR}

ÀQDQFLDGR SHOD )$3(63 H GHVHQYROYLGR QR 'HSDUWDPHQWR GH )LORVRÀD GD 8QLYHUVLGDGH GH 0DVVDFKXVHWWVHP$PKHUVW(VWDGRV8QLGRVVREDVXSHUYLVmRGDÀOyVRID/\QQH5XGGHU%DNHU

(2)

´([WHUQDOLVPR6RFLDOµFRQVLGHUDQGRQmRDSHQDVRVHXSUySULRSHQVDPHQWRPDV WDPEpPDDERUGDJHPGHXPÀOyVRIRTXHPXLWRDLQÁXHQFLRXRXVHMD7\OHU%XUJH $UJXPHQWDUHLTXHDLPSRUWkQFLDTXHHVVHVSHQVDGRUHVDWULEXHPjOLQJXDJHPQDV TXHVW}HV UHODWLYDV j PHQWH QmR VLJQLÀFD QHFHVVDULDPHQWH HPERUD VHXV WH[WRV PXLWDV YH]HV R VXJLUDP D UHGXomR GD PHQWH j OLQJXDJHP_{e, muito menos, a}

HOLPLQDomR GD PHQWH (OHV DVVXPHP XPD SRVLomR PHWRGROyJLFD REMHWLYLVWD D TXDOFRQVLVWHHP´GHVFRQVLGHUDUQDSUiWLFDµRVIDWRUHVSXUDPHQWHVXEMHWLYRVRX LQWHUQRVGDPHQWHRSRQGRVHGHVVHPRGRjWUDGLFLRQDOÀORVRÀDGDOLQJXDJHP TXH+LODU\3XWQDPFKDPDGH´6ROLSVLVPR0HWRGROyJLFRµSHORIDWRGHDTXHOD ´GHVFRQVLGHUDUQDSUiWLFDµRVIDWRUHVH[WHUQRVjPHQWHRXVHMDDVRFLHGDGHR PXQGRQDWXUDOHDWpRSUySULRFRUSR

4XDQGR RV ÀOyVRIRV WUDGLFLRQDLV IDODUDP VREUH HVWDGRV SVLFROyJLFRV RX HVWDGRV´PHQWDLVµHOHVVXSXVHUDPRTXHQyVSRGHPRVFKDPDUGHVROLSVLVPR PHWRGROyJLFR(VWDpDVXSRVLomRGHTXHQHQKXPHVWDGRSVLFROyJLFRDVVLP SURSULDPHQWHFKDPDGRSUHVVXS}HDH[LVWrQFLDGHTXDOTXHULQGLYtGXRDOpPGR VXMHLWR D TXHP DTXHOH HVWDGR p DWULEXtGR 'H IDWR D VXSRVLomR HUD GH TXH QHQKXP HVWDGR SVLFROyJLFR SUHVVXS}H D H[LVWrQFLD QHP PHVPR GR FRUSR VH3pXPHVWDGRSVLFROyJLFRDVVLPSURSULDPHQWHFKDPDGRHQWmRGHYHVHU ORJLFDPHQWH SRVVtYHO SDUD XPD PHQWH ´QmR LQFRUSRUDGDµ HVWDU HP 3 (VWD VXSRVLomRHVWiEHPH[SOtFLWDHP'HVFDUWHVPDVHVWiLPSOtFLWDHPTXDVHWRGRR FRQMXQWRGDSVLFRORJLDÀORVyÀFDWUDGLFLRQDO3871$0S

$TXHVWmRTXHPHSDUHFHFUXFLDOQDUHÁH[mRSURSRVWDpDFRPSUHHQVmR TXHR([WHUQDOLVPR6RFLDOGH7\OHU%XUJHH/\QQH%DNHUWHPVREUHDUHODomR HQWUHPHQWHSHQVDPHQWRHOLQJXDJHP2SRQWRDVHUHQIDWL]DGRpTXHDRGHÀQLU RSHQVDPHQWRHPWHUPRVGHDWLWXGHVSURSRVLFLRQDLVWDLVFRPRFUHQoDVGHVHMRVH LQWHQo}HVHSULYLOHJLDUFRQFHLWRVFRPRFRQWH~GRGRSHQVDPHQWRR([WHUQDOLVPR 6RFLDO SUHRFXSDVH IXQGDPHQWDOPHQWH FRP DV FRQGLo}HV H[WHUQDV QDWXUDLV H SULQFLSDOPHQWHVRFLDLVGHLQGLYLGXDOL]DomRGRSHQVDPHQWRRXGHDSOLFDomRGRV FRQFHLWRV'HL[DSRLVGHODGRDVSHFWRVTXDOLWDWLYRVGDVH[SHULrQFLDVVXEMHWLYDV RVTXDLVQmRVHULDPGHÀQLGRVFRPRSHQVDPHQWRHPERUDVHMDPHQWHQGLGRVFRPR HYHQWRVPHQWDLVLQWHUQRV(VVDVHSDUDomRHQWUHRVDVSHFWRVTXDOLWDWLYRVGDPHQWH SRU PXLWRV WLGRV FRPR SULPLWLYRV H LQIHULRUHV H RV DVSHFWRV SURSRVLFLRQDLV H FRQFHLWXDLVGDPHQWHVXSRVWDPHQWHVXSHULRUHVHPERUDFRQWULEXDSDUDUHVVDOWDURV JDQKRVLQTXHVWLRQiYHLVTXHDOLQJXDJHPHDYLGDVRFLDOWUD]HPSDUDRSHQVDPHQWR

_{eRTXHSRGHPRVREVHUYDUQDPDQHLUDSHODTXDO/\QQH%DNHUWUDWDGRSUREOHPDGDFDXVDomRPHQWDO}

(3)

LQGLYLGXDOSRGHFRPRIULVDGRJHUDUDLGHLDDPHXYHUHTXLYRFDGDGHTXHHVWH pRFDPLQKRSDUDVHVROXFLRQDURXGLVVROYHUSUREOHPDVÀORVyÀFRVIXQGDPHQWDLV WDLVFRPRRGDQDWXUH]DGDPHQWHHVXDUHODomRFRPRFRUSRRVTXDLVUHVXOWDPGH

abordagens internalistas e individualistas da mente.

/HPEUHPRV D SDUDGLJPiWLFD GHÀQLomR LQWHUQDOLVWD GH SHQVDPHQWR LVWR p D FRQFHSomR GH 'HVFDUWHV TXH FRPR VH VDEH FRQVLGHUD R SHQVDPHQWR HP VXDV YiULDV IRUPDV FRPR D SUySULD HVVrQFLD RX SURSULHGDGH HVVHQFLDO GD DOPD RXPHQWHLPDWHULDOLQH[WHQVDHLQGLYLVtYHOLUUHGXWtYHOjOLQJXDJHP(VWDSRUVXD YH]pDSUHVHQWDGDFRPRDIHUUDPHQWDGRFRUSRPDWHULDOH[WHQVRHGLYLVtYHOQmR DSHQDVSDUDDH[SUHVVmRGRSHQVDPHQWRGDDOPDPDVSDUDDWHVWLÀFDomRGHVXD H[LVWrQFLD'HVVHPRGRDFRQFHSomRFDUWHVLDQDGDUHODomRHQWUHSHQVDPHQWRH OLQJXDJHPpFRUUHODWDGHVXDRQWRORJLDGXDOLVWDFXMRVSUREOHPDVHPHVSHFLDOR GDUHODomRHXQLmRHQWUHPHQWHHFRUSRMiIRUDPDPSODPHQWHUHVVDOWDGRVSHORV FUtWLFRV GH 'HVFDUWHV 6H FRPR SUHWHQGR PRVWUDU SDUD R ([WHUQDOLVPR 6RFLDO DH[WHUQDOL]DomRGRVLJQLÀFDGRQmRVLJQLÀFDDH[WHUQDOL]DomRRXHOLPLQDomRGD PHQWHHVVDDERUGDJHPQmRVHULDXPDDOWHUQDWLYDVDWLVIDWyULDGHHQIUHQWDPHQWR PDLV SUHFLVDPHQWH GH GHVFRQVWUXomR GH SUREOHPDV ÀORVyÀFRV GHFRUUHQWHV GH XPDFRQFHSomRLQWHUQDOLVWDGDPHQWHHPHVSHFLDORVSUREOHPDVGDQDWXUH]DGD PHQWHHGHVXDUHODomRFRPRFRUSRMiFLWDGRVDQWHULRUPHQWH6HQGRRFDVRR YDORULQTXHVWLRQiYHOGR([WHUQDOLVPR6RFLDOHVWDULDOLPLWDGRDHQIDWL]DUHHOXFLGDU DLPSRUWkQFLDGDOLQJXDJHPSDUDRSHQVDPHQWRHSULQFLSDOPHQWHGDVRFLHGDGH HGRPXQGRSDUDDOLQJXDJHP&RPRUHVVDOWDH[SOLFLWDPHQWH+LODU\3XWQDP´$ ÀORVRÀD WUDGLFLRQDO GD OLQJXDJHP FRPR JUDQGH SDUWH GD ÀORVRÀD WUDGLFLRQDO GHL[DGHIRUDDVRXWUDVSHVVRDVHRPXQGRXPDPHOKRUÀORVRÀDHXPDPHOKRU FLrQFLDGDOLQJXDJHPGHYHPDEDUFDUDPERVµ3871$0S

(4)

2 O ANTI-INDIVIDUALISMO DE TYLER BURGE

$V PLQKDV FRQVLGHUDo}HV VREUH R ([WHUQDOLVPR 6RFLDO GH 7\OHU %XUJH FRPHoDUmRSHODVXDFUtWLFDjLQWHUSUHWDomRGH+LODU\3XWQDPTXDQWRDRH[SHULPHQWR GHSHQVDPHQWRSRUHOHPHVPRSURSRVWRTXHUGL]HURGDV7HUUDV*rPHDV

Grosso modoRH[SHULPHQWRGHSHQVDPHQWRGH3XWQDPpH[SRVWRSRU%XUJH

QRV VHJXLQWHV WHUPRV 6XSRQKDPRV TXH H[LVWD XP SODQHWD TXH VHMD XPD FySLD LGrQWLFDGHQRVVRSODQHWD7HUUDHPWRGRVRVDVSHFWRVItVLFRVHKLVWyULFRVLQFOXLQGR VHFySLDVLGrQWLFDVGRVKDELWDQWHVGD7HUUD²*rPHRV7HUUHVWUHV²FRPD~QLFD GLIHUHQoDGHTXHQD7HUUD*rPHDDFRPSRVLomRTXtPLFDGRTXHDTXLFKDPDPRV GHíJXDµQmRp+2PDV;<=$SHVDUGDVVHPHOKDQoDVQRQtYHOPDFURItVLFR %XUJHFRQFRUGDFRPDLQWHUSUHWDomRGH3XWQDPVHJXQGRDTXDOHPYLUWXGHGD GLIHUHQoDPLFURItVLFDROtTXLGRTXHQD7HUUD*rPHDpWDPEpPFKDPDGRGHíJXDµ SHORVQRVVRVJrPHRVQmRVHULDQDYHUGDGHiJXD´(XLUHLDSHQDVDVVXPLUTXH;<= QmRpiJXDGHQHQKXPWLSRÉJXDp+2µS'Dt%XUJHGHIHQGHU TXHVHHQFRQWUiVVHPRVQD7HUUDRPHVPROtTXLGRGD7HUUD*rPHDDSDUHQWHPHQWH LGrQWLFRjiJXDWHUUHVWUHHPERUDTXLPLFDPHQWHGLIHUHQWHVHULDPDLVDSURSULDGR FKDPiORSRUH[HPSORGH´WiJXDµDRLQYpVGHíJXDµ

(5)

DWLWXGHVSURSRVLFLRQDLVGRVJrPHRVVHULDPDWLWXGHVde reTXHUGL]HURVres, no caso

+2H;<=VHULDPGLIHUHQWHVPDVRVFRQWH~GRVGDVDWLWXGHVVHULDPLGrQWLFRV %XUJHSHQVDLUPDLVORQJHGRTXH3XWQDPDRSRVWXODUTXHDGLIHUHQoD HQWUHRVJrPHRVQmRVHUHVWULQJHjH[WHQVmRGRVWHUPRVSRUHOHVHPSUHJDGRV PDVGL]UHVSHLWRDRVSUySULRVFRQWH~GRVGHVHXVSHQVDPHQWRVRTXHVLJQLÀFD TXH WHUPRV GH HVSpFLH QDWXUDO WDLV FRPR ´iJXDµ QmR VHULDP LQGH[LFDLV ´$ H[WHQVmRGH¶iJXD·WDOFRPRLQWHUSUHWDGDHPSRUWXJXrVHPWRGRVRVFRQWH[WRV QmRREOtTXRV_p_{grosso modo}_{RFRQMXQWRGHWRGRVRVDJUHJDGRVGHPROpFXODVGH}

+2MXQWRSURYDYHOPHQWHFRPDVPROpFXODVLQGLYLGXDLV1mRH[LVWHGHPRGR DOJXPQDGDGHLQGH[LFDODUHVSHLWRGH¶iJXD·QRVHQWLGRFRVWXPHLURGH¶LQGH[LFDO·µ %85*(S2XVHMDHQTXDQWRSDUD3XWQDPDSDODYUDíJXDµWHULD RPHVPRVLJQLÀFDGRLQGH[LFDOLGDGHPDVH[WHQV}HVGLIHUHQWHVQDVGXDV7HUUDV SDUD%XUJHDSDODYUDíJXDµWHULDVLJQLÀFDGRVGLIHUHQWHV$SDODYUDíJXDµQmR PXGDULDDVXDH[WHQVmRQD7HUUD*rPHDSHORVLPSOHVIDWRGHOiQmRKDYHUiJXD PDVDSHQDVWiJXD´2IDWRGHRV*rPHRV7HUUHVWUHVDSOLFDUHP¶iJXD·D;<=QmR pXPUHÁH[RGHXPDPXGDQoDGHH[WHQVmRGHXPDH[SUHVVmRLQGH[LFDOFRPXP VLJQLÀFDGROLQJtVWLFRÀ[RSRUWXJXrVPDVGHXPDPXGDQoDGHVLJQLÀFDGRHQWUH XPDOtQJXDHFRPXQLGDGHOLQJtVWLFDHRXWUDµ%85*(S'HIDWR Ki XPD PXGDQoD QR SUySULR FRQWH~GR GR SHQVDPHQWR RX HVWDGR PHQWDO GRV JrPHRVFRQIRUPHSRGHPRVREVHUYDUQDVFRQVLGHUDo}HVGH%XUJHDEDL[R

$V GLIHUHQoDV QmR GHYHP VHU DVVLPLODGDV D GLIHUHQoDV QDV H[WHQV}HV GH H[SUHVV}HV LQGH[LFDLV FRP R PHVPR FRQVWDQWH VLJQLÀFDGR OLQJtVWLFR 2V WHUPRV UHOHYDQWHV QmR VmR LQGH[LFDLV $V GLIHUHQoDV DQWHV HQYROYHP D FRQVWDQWH LQWHUSUHWDomR GRV WHUPRV OLYUH GR FRQWH[WR $V DWULEXLo}HV GH DWLWXGHV SURSRVLFLRQDLV DV TXDLV FRORFDP RV WHUPRV HP RFRUUrQFLD REOtTXD DIHWDUmRGHVWHPRGRRFRQWH~GRGDVDWLWXGHVSURSRVLFLRQDLV'HVGHTXHRV DWRV H HVWDGRV PHQWDLV VmR LQGLYLGXDGRV SDUFLDOPHQWH HP WHUPRV GH VHXV FRQWH~GRVDVGLIHUHQoDVHQWUH7HUUDH7HUUD*rPHDLQFOXHPGLIHUHQoDVQRV DWRVHHVWDGRVPHQWDLVGHVHXVKDELWDQWHV%85*(S

_{2TXHVHULDPHVVDVH[SUHVV}HVGHRFRUUrQFLDREOtTXD"6HJXQGR7\OHU%XUJHVHULDPH[SUHVV}HVTXH}

(6)

$FUtWLFDGH%XUJHD3XWQDPHDGLIHUHQoDSRUHVWHDSUHVHQWDGDHQWUHDPEDV DVLQWHUSUHWDo}HVGRH[SHULPHQWRGHSHQVDPHQWRGDV7HUUDV*rPHDVWRUQDPVH PDLVFODUDVTXDQGRVHWHPHPYLVWDDGLVWLQomRHVWDEHOHFLGDSRU3XWQDPHQWUH LQWHQVmRHH[WHQVmRHPWHUPRVGDGLIHUHQoDHQWUH´VHQWLGRHVWUHLWRµH´VHQWLGR DPSORµ GH XP HVWDGR SVLFROyJLFR DRV TXDLV VH DVVRFLDULDP UHVSHFWLYDPHQWH

atitudes de dicto e atitudes de re(PVHXVHQWLGRHVWUHLWRRHVWDGRSVLFROyJLFRGH

XPD SHVVRD À[DULD D H[WHQVmR GRV WHUPRV SRU HOD XWLOL]DGRV SDUD H[SUHVVDU DV VXDV DWLWXGHVSURSRVLFLRQDLV SULYLOHJLDQGRVH GHVVH PRGR R HVWDGR GD SHVVRD H GHVFRQVLGHUDQGRVH LQGLYLGXDOLGDGHV H[WHUQDV D HOD &RQVHTXHQWHPHQWH RV HVWDGRV SVLFROyJLFRV GRV JrPHRV FRQVLGHUDGRV HP VHX VHQWLGR HVWUHLWR QmR À[DULDP´DVH[WHQV}HVGRVWHUPRVTXHHOHVXVDPµDVTXDLVVHULDPGLIHUHQWHVLVWR pRVJrPHRVWHULDPDSHQDVDPHVPDDWLWXGHSURSRVLFLRQDOde dicto.

$VDWLWXGHVSURSRVLFLRQDLVQmRUHODFLRQDLVde dicto seriam desse modo estados

SVLFROyJLFRVQRVHQWLGRHVWUHLWR(ODVQmRH[LJHPSRUJHQHUDOL]DomRH[LVWHQFLDO D H[LVWrQFLD GH QHQKXPD HQWLGDGH DOpP GR VXMHLWR H VHXV FRQWH~GRV GH SHQVDPHQWR $WLWXGHV SURSRVLFLRQDLVde re ² SHOR PHQRV DTXHODV DWLWXGHV

SURSRVLFLRQDLVde reQDVTXDLVRVXMHLWRpFDUDFWHUL]DGRFRPRHVWDQGRHPUHODomR

FRPDOJXPDRXWUDFRLVDDOpPGHOHPHVPRHGHVHXVFRQWH~GRVGHSHQVDPHQWR ²SDUHFHPVHUHVWDGRVSVLFROyJLFRVQR´VHQWLGRDPSORµ7HUDWLWXGHVde re em

UHODomRDdeREMHWRVRXWURVDOpPGHVLPHVPRH[LJHDH[LVWrQFLDGHRXWURV

REMHWRVDOpPGHVLPHVPR%85*(S

%XUJH GLVFRUGD GHVVD LQWHUSUHWDomR GR H[SHULPHQWR GH SHQVDPHQWR $UJXPHQWDSULPHLUDPHQWHTXHRVJrPHRVHPVXDVUHVSHFWLYDV7HUUDV*rPHDV QmRWrPDWLWXGHVUHIHUHQWHVjiJXDFRPRPHVPRFRQWH~GR'HIDWRQD7HUUD *rPHD QLQJXpP SRGHULD WHU SHQVDPHQWRV HQYROYHQGR R FRQFHLWR GH iJXD OHYDQGRVHHPFRQWDTXHQLQJXpPWHYHFRQWDWRFRPiJXDQHPFRPDOJXpPTXH WLYHVVHWLGRHVVHFRQWDWR$ÀQDOOiQmRH[LVWHiJXD

(7)

(PVHJXQGROXJDUYLVWRTXHQmRH[LVWHiJXDQD7HUUD*rPHDVHRJrPHR LGrQWLFRIRVVHFDSD]GHDWLWXGHVTXHHQYROYHVVHPRFRQFHLWRGHiJXDFRPRRSRVWR GRFRQFHLWRWiJXDPXLWDVGHVXDVFUHQoDVGLIHUHQWHPHQWHGDVFUHQoDVGRRXWUR JrPHRDUHVSHLWRGDiJXDVHULDPIDOVDV3RUH[HPSORVHULDPIDOVDVDVFUHQoDVGH TXHH[LVWHiJXDRXGHTXHRVFLHQWLVWDVFRQKHFHPDHVWUXWXUDTXtPLFDGDiJXD 0DVSDUHFHQmRID]HUVHQWLGRFRQVLGHUDUTXHDVVXDVFUHQoDVVmRIDOVDVSRUTXH HODV´>@IRUDPDGTXLULGDVHUHODFLRQDGDVDVHXVDPELHQWHVGHPRGRVH[DWDPHQWH SDUDOHORVHLJXDOPHQWHEHPVXFHGLGRVµ%85*(S$HVVHUHVSHLWRD FRQFOXVmRGH%XUJHpDVHJXLQWH

$VGLIHUHQoDVHQWUHDVDWLWXGHVGH$GDPH$GDPGHULYDPQmRGHGLIHUHQoDVQR YDORUGHYHUGDGHPDVGHGLIHUHQoDVHPVHXVUHVSHFWLYRVDPELHQWHVHFRQWH[WRV VRFLDLV(OHVGmRGLIHUHQWHVWLSRVGHHQWLGDGHVFRPRFDVRVSDUDGLJPiWLFRVGH H[HPSORV GR WHUPR 6HXV XVRV GRV WHUPRV HVWmR HPEHELGRV HP GLIHUHQWHV XVRVFRPXQLWiULRVHWUDGLo}HVFLHQWtÀFDVRVTXDLVGmRDRWHUPRGLIHUHQWHVH FRQVWDQWHV VLJQLÀFDGRV FRQYHQFLRQDLV (P FRQWH[WRV QRUPDLV HOHV SRGHP H[SOLFDU H XVDU R WHUPR GH PRGRV TXH VmR LQIRUPDWLYRV H VRFLDOPHQWH DFHLWiYHLV GHQWUR GH VXDV UHVSHFWLYDV FRPXQLGDGHV $R ID]rOR GHVVH PRGR HOHVH[SUHVVDPGLIHUHQWHVQRo}HVHGLIHUHQWHVSHQVDPHQWRVFRPHVVDVSDODYUDV 6HXVSHQVDPHQWRVHDÀUPDo}HVWrPGLIHUHQWHVFRQGLo}HVGHYHUGDGHHVmR YHUGDGHGHGLIHUHQWHVWLSRVGHHQWLGDGHV%85*(S

(QWUHWDQWR %XUJH VH FRORFD FRQWUD HVVD FRQFHSomR GH 3XWQDP TXH SUHVHUYDDRODGRGDGLIHUHQoDHQWUHDVDWLWXGHVSURSRVLFLRQDLVUHODFLRQDLVDWLWXGHV SURSRVLFLRQDLVHPVHQWLGRDPSORDLGHQWLGDGHHQWUHDVDWLWXGHVde dicto, atitudes

QR VHQWLGR HVWUHLWR GRV JrPHRV 3DUD %XUJH RV FRQWH~GRV GH SHQVDPHQWR GLIHUHPPHVPRQRFDVRGHDWLWXGHVSXUDPHQWHde dictoRXVHMD´>@SDUDVDEHU

HH[SOLFDURTXHXPDSHVVRDDFUHGLWDde dictoVHGHYHWLSLFDPHQWHVDEHUDOJXPD

FRLVDVREUHRTXHHODDFUHGLWDde reVREUHRTXHRVVHXVSDUHVDFUHGLWDPde re

Hde dicto VREUH TXH HQWLGDGHV HOHV RVWHQWDP VREUH R TXH DV VXDV SDODYUDV H

DGHVHXVSDUHVVLJQLÀFDPHVREUHTXHHQWLGDGHVFDHPQDVH[WHQV}HVGHVHXV WHUPRVµ %85*( S ( LVVR VLJQLÀFDTXH´>@VHSRGH H[SOLFDU R

conteúdoGDDWLWXGHSURSRVLFLRQDOGHXPDSHVVRDFRQVLGHUDQGRVHDSHQDVRVIDWRV

VREUH HOD TXH VmR QmRLQWHQFLRQDLV H QmRLQGLYLGXDOtVWLFRVµ %85*( S &RQIRUPH%XUJHQmRH[LVWHPHVWDGRVSVLFROyJLFRVQRVHQWLGRHVWUHLWRSRLV

tanto as atitudes de dictoTXDQWRDVDWLWXGHVde reGHSHQGHPGHHOHPHQWRVH[WHUQRV

DRLQGLYtGXRLVWRpQmRDSHQDVGDVHQWLGDGHVjVTXDLVHOHVHUHIHUHPDVWDPEpP GDFRPXQLGDGHVRFLDOHOLQJXtVWLFDQDTXDOHVWiLQVHULGR

3RGHUVHLDGL]HUTXHDVDWLWXGHVde dictoGH$GDPHQYROYHQGRDQRomRGHiJXD

(8)

DDo}HVHDWLWXGHVGHRXWURVQDFRPXQLGDGH0HVPRDWLWXGHVSURSRVLFLRQDLV SXUDPHQWHde dictoSUHVVXS}HPDH[LVWrQFLDGHHQWLGDGHVRXWUDVTXHRVXMHLWR

QHVVHVHQWLGRGHSUHVVXSRVLomR6HJXQGRHVVHFRQVWUXWRnenhuma das atitudes relevantes, de re ou de dicto VmR HVWDGRV SVLFROyJLFRV QR VHQWLGR HVWUHLWR

%85*(S

3DUD PHOKRU FRPSUHHQGHU HVVD FRQFHSomR H[WHUQDOLVWD GR SHQVDPHQWR GHIHQGLGDSRU7\OHU%XUJHYHULÀTXHPRVDVXDMXVWLÀFDWLYDDSDUWLUGHXPGHVHXV H[HPSORVRGDGRHQoDDUWULWHDSUHVHQWDGRHPWUrVSDVVRVQRWH[WR´,QGLYLGXDOLVP DQGWKHPHQWDOµ2SULPHLURSDVVRFRQVLVWHQDGHVFULomRGRVSHQVDPHQWRVGHXPD SHVVRDTXHWHPFUHQoDVYHUGDGHLUDVHIDOVDVDUHVSHLWRGDDUWULWH&RUUHWDPHQWH HVVDSHVVRDSHQVDTXH´>@WHPDUWULWHKiYiULRVDQRVTXHVXDDUWULWHHPVHXVSXOVRV HGHGRVpPDLVGRORURVDGRTXHVXDDUWULWHHPVHXVWRUQR]HORVTXHpPHOKRUWHU DWULWHGRTXHFkQFHUGHItJDGRTXHRHQGXUHFLPHQWRGDVMXQWDVpXPVLQWRPDGD DUWULWHTXHFHUWRVWLSRVGHGRUHVVmRFDUDFWHUtVWLFDVGDDUWULWHTXHH[LVWHPYiULRV WLSRV GH DUWULWHV H DVVLP SRU GLDQWHµ %85*( S ,QFRUUHWDPHQWH HVVDPHVPDSHVVRDDFUHGLWDTXHDVXDDUWULWHHVWiWDPEpPDIHWDQGRDVXDFR[D (VVDFUHQoDIDOVDpFRUULJLGDSHORPpGLFRTXHHVFODUHFHRSDFLHQWHH[SOLFLWDQGR DPHVPDGHÀQLomRGHDUWULWHTXHDSDUHFHQRVGLFLRQiULRVTXHUGL]HU´>@TXHD DUWULWHpHVSHFLÀFDPHQWHXPDLQÁDPDomRQDVMXQWDVµ%85*(S

2 VHJXQGR SDVVR GR H[SHULPHQWR GH SHQVDPHQWR D UHVSHLWR GD DUWULWH FRQVLVWH QD DSUHVHQWDomR GH XPD VLWXDomR FRQWUDIDFWXDO QD TXDO D GHÀQLomR GH DUWULWHLQFOXLDVGRUHVQDFR[D7HUtDPRVHQWmRXPDSHVVRDQDVPHVPDVFRQGLo}HV ItVLFDVÀVLROyJLFDV IHQRPHQDLV QmRLQWHQFLRQDLV H OLQJXtVWLFDV LQFOXLQGRVH D VHTXrQFLD KLVWyULFD GH VHXV HYHQWRV H LQWHUDo}HV ItVLFDV H OLQJXtVWLFDV FRP VHX

ambiente natural e cultural, as mesmas dores, inclusive na coxa, e o mesmo uso da

SDODYUD´DUWULWHµDSUHQGLGDSRUH[HPSORDWUDYpVGDFRQYHUVDFRPRXWUDVSHVVRDV HRPHVPRUHODWRSDUDRPpGLFR$~QLFDGLIHUHQoDQHVVDQRYDVLWXDomRFRQFHUQH DRXVRGDSDODYUD´DUWULWHµSHODFRPXQLGDGHOHLJDHPpGLFD(ODWHPXPXVRPDLV DEUDQJHQWHRTXDOLQFOXLDOpPGRVVLQWRPDVGHVFULWRVDQWHULRUPHQWHYiULDVRXWUDV GRHQoDVUHXPDWRLGHVLQFOXVLYHDVGRUHVQDFR[D´$SHVVRDSRGHULDWHUWLGRDPHVPD KLVWyULDItVLFDHIHQ{PHQRPHQWDOQmRLQWHQFLRQDOHQTXDQWRDSDODYUD¶DUWULWH·IRVVH FRQYHQFLRQDOPHQWHDSOLFDGDHGHÀQLGDSDUDDSOLFDUDYiULDVGRHQoDVUHXPDWyLGHV LQFOXVLYHXPDQDFR[DGDSHVVRDWmREHPFRPRDUWULWHµ%85*(S

(9)

´DUWULWHµSHODFRPXQLGDGHHQmRRVFRQWH~GRVGRVHVWDGRVPHQWDLVGRVLQGLYtGXRV RVTXDLVSHUPDQHFHULDPLGrQWLFRV'HDFRUGRFRPRÀOyVRIRDLQGDTXHDKLVWyULD ItVLFDHPHQWDOQmRLQWHQFLRQDOGRSDFLHQWHVHMDDPHVPDQDVLWXDomRFRQWUDIDWXDO RVFRQWH~GRVGHVXDVRUDo}HVPHQWDLVRXVHMDRVVHXVSHQVDPHQWRVRXDWLWXGHV FRPR SRU H[HPSOR FUHQoDV UHIHUHQWHV DRV FRQWH~GRV GH RUDo}HV GD SDODYUD ´DUWULWHµVmRGLIHUHQWHV,VVRVHGiHPYLUWXGHGDGLIHUHQoDGRFRQWH[WRVRFLDO SRUWDQWRGHGLIHUHQoDVTXHVmRH[WHUQDVDRSDFLHQWH

$SDODYUD´DUWULWHµQDFRPXQLGDGHFRQWUDIDWXDOQmRVLJQLÀFDartrite(ODQmR

VHDSOLFDDSHQDVDLQÁDPDomRQDVMXQWDV1yVVXSRPRVTXHQHQKXPDRXWUD SDODYUD QR UHSHUWyULR GR SDFLHQWH VLJQLÀFDartrite ´$UWULWHµ QD VLWXDomR

FRQWUDIDWXDOGLIHUHWDQWRQDGHÀQLomRGRGLFLRQiULRTXDQWRQDH[WHQVmRGH ´DUWULWHµ FRPR QyV D XVDPRV >@ 'HVVH PRGR RV FRQWH~GRV GD DWLWXGH FRQWUDIDWXDOGRSDFLHQWHGLIHUHPGRVFRQWH~GRVGHVXDDWLWXGHUHDO>@(P VXPDDVH[SHULrQFLDVTXDOLWDWLYDVLQWHUQDVGRSDFLHQWHVHXVHVWDGRVHHYHQWRV ÀVLROyJLFRV VHXV HVWtPXORV H UHVSRVWDV FRPSRUWDPHQWDOPHQWH GHVFULWRV DV VXDVGLVSRVLo}HVSDUDFRPSRUWDUVHHTXDOTXHUVHTrQFLDGHHVWDGRVQmR LQWHQFLRQDOPHQWH GHVFULWRV PHGLDGRUHV GH VHX LQSXW H RXWSXW ² WXGR LVVR SHUPDQHFH FRQVWDQWH HQTXDQWR TXH RV FRQWH~GRV GH VXD DWLWXGH GLIHUHP PHVPR QDV H[WHQV}HV GDV QRo}HV FRQWUDSDUWH &RPR QyV REVHUYDPRV QR LQtFLRHVVDVGLIHUHQoDVRUGLQDULDPHQWHUHVXOWDPHPGLIHUHQoDVQRVHVWDGRVH HYHQWRVPHQWDLV%85*(S

6HJXQGR%XUJHVHKRXYHVVHXPDVLWXDomRLQYHUWLGDQDTXDORSDFLHQWH WLYHVVHXPDFRPSUHHQVmRFRPSOHWDHFRUUHWDGDSDODYUD´DUWULWHµRXVHMDXPD FRPSUHHQVmR TXH H[FOXtVVH D DUWULWH QD FR[D UHVWULQJLQGRD jV MXQWDV PDV QD TXDO R SDFLHQWH IRVVH FRUULJLGR SHOR PpGLFR R TXDO OKH GLULD TXH DUWULWH SRGH RFRUUHUHPRXWUDVSDUWHVGRFRUSRWDLVFRPRP~VFXORVWHQG}HVHWFDSOLFDQGRVH DVVLPDSDODYUD´DUWULWHµDWRGRVRVWLSRVGHGRHQoDVUHXPDWyLGHVD´>@QRomR FRPDTXDORPpGLFRHRSDFLHQWHHVWDULDPRSHUDQGRHPWDOFDVRQmRVHULDDGH DUWULWHµ%85*(S2TXHRH[SHULPHQWRGHSHQVDPHQWRSUHWHQGH PRVWUDUHPVXDVGXDVYHUV}HVDQRUPDOHDLQYHUWLGDpTXHFRQWH~GRGHXP SHQVDPHQWRRXHYHQWRPHQWDORXVHMDRVLJQLÀFDGRGHXPDQRomRLQFRPSOHWD RXFRPSOHWDGHSHQGHGHIDWRUHVH[WHUQRVDRVXMHLWRQmRGDVSURSULHGDGHVPLFUR RXPDFURHVWUXWXUDLVGRPXQGRPDVGDFRPXQLGDGHFXOWXUDOHOLQJXtVWLFDQDTXDO RVXMHLWRHVWiLQVHULGR

(10)

DVSHFWRVTXDOLWDWLYRVRXIHQRPHQDLVRXVHMDQmRLQWHQFLRQDLVGRVFRQWH~GRVGR SHQVDPHQWRGHXPLQGLYtGXR&RPRHQIDWL]DDLQGD%XUJHQmRVHDSOLFDWDPEpP jVQRo}HVRXFRQWH~GRVGHSHQVDPHQWRHQYROYHQGRRVYHUERVSVLFROyJLFRVWDLV FRPR´FRQKHFHUµÓDPHQWDUµ´QRWDUµÓHPEUDUµ´SUHYHUµH´SHUFHEHUµ2TXH GLVWLQJXLULDHVVHVYHUERVGDSDODYUD´DUWULWHµ"$MXVWLÀFDWLYDGH%XUJHpTXHHVVHV YHUERVVXJHUHPXPD´>@IiFLOHFODUDGLVWLQomRHQWUHDFRQWULEXLomRGRVXMHLWR LQGLYLGXDOHDREMHWLYDÝHUtGLFDµFRQWULEXLomRGRDPELHQWHSDUDWRUQDURVYHUERV DSOLFiYHLVµ S $LQGD TXH HP WDLV FDVRV D LPSRUWkQFLD GR DPELHQWH QDWXUDOSUHYDOHoDVREUHRDPELHQWHOLQJXtVWLFRFXOWXUDOHOHVVHUHVWULQJLULDPDRV HVWDGRV PHQWDLV LQWHQFLRQDLV GRV LQGLYtGXRV QmR YDOHQGR SRUWDQWR SDUD RV DVSHFWRVQmRLQWHQFLRQDLVGRVFRQWH~GRVGHSHQVDPHQWR

4XDQGRXPDSHVVRDVDEHTXHpFRPXPQHYDUHP*UHHQODQGVHXFRQKHFLPHQWR REYLDPHQWHGHSHQGHPDLVGRTXHGRPRGRHPTXHDSHVVRDHVWi(OHGHSHQGH GHTXHKDMDUHDOPHQWHXPERFDGRGHQHYHHP*UHHQODQG2VHXHVWDGRPHQWDO DFUHQoDGHTXHDQHYHpFRPXPHP*UHHQODQGGHYHVHUEHPVXFHGLGRGHXP FHUWRPRGRYHUGDGHLUR0XGDQGRRDPELHQWHVHSRGHPXGDURYDORUGHYHUGDGH GRFRQWH~GRGHWDOPRGRTXHQmRPDLVVHSRGHGL]HUTXHRVXMHLWRFRQKHFHR FRQWH~GR e SDUWH GD FDUJD GH QRVVR DUJXPHQWR TXH PHVPR HVWDGRV PHQWDLV LQWHQFLRQDLVGRVLQGLYtGXRVWDLVFRPRDVFUHQFDVRVTXDLVQmRWrPLPSOLFDo}HV SDUDYHUGDGHRXVXFHVVRQmRSRGHPVHUHQWHQGLGRVIRFDQGRVHSXUDPHQWHHP DWRVGRVLQGLYtGXRVGLVSRVLo}HVH´LQWHUQRµDFRQWHFHQGR%85*(S

(QÀP R TXH HVWRX GHIHQGHQGR p TXH Mi SRGHPRV HQWUHYHU QDV FRQVLGHUDo}HV DQWHULRUHV GH %XUJH TXH D VXD FRQFHSomR H[WHUQDOLVWD GR SHQVDPHQWRQmRDFDUUHWDDUHGXomRGDPHQWHDVXDUHODomRFRPRDPELHQWHQHP DOJXPWLSRGHHOLPLQDomRGDPHQWHHQWHQGLGDHPVHXVDVSHFWRVSXUDPHQWHLQWHUQRV HLQGLYLGXDLVeRTXHHQFRQWUDPRVH[SOLFLWDPHQWHDÀUPDGRSRU%XUJHHPVHX

livro recente Origins of ObjectivityDRFRPSDUDUDUHODomRHQWUHDVSODFDVWHFW{QLFDV

HRDPELHQWHJHROyJLFRFRPDUHODomRHQWUHRVHYHQWRVPHQWDLVHRDPELHQWH ItVLFRHOLQJXtVWLFR(OHUHVVDOWDTXHRVHUXPDSODFDWHFW{QLFDGHSHQGHHPSDUWHGH UHODo}HVFDXVDLVH[WHUQDVDHODWDLVFRPRRXWUDVSODFDVIRUoDVHPDVVDVJHROyJLFDV VREUHDVTXDLVHVFRUUHJDPRXFRPDVTXDLVVHFKRFDP0DVLVVRQmRVLJQLÀFDTXH VHSRVVDUHGX]LUDVSODFDVJHROyJLFDVDHVVDVUHODo}HVFRQVLGHUDQGRVHTXHHODV WrPXPDHVWUXWXUDLQWHUQDGHODVLQGHSHQGHQWH$OJRVHPHOKDQWHDFRQWHFHULDFRP RVHVWDGRVPHQWDLVHPVXDUHODomRFRPRDPELHQWH

2 DQWLLQGLYLGXDOLVPR GHIHQGH TXH D QDWXUH]D GH PXLWRV HVWDGRV PHQWDLV GHSHQGHFRQVWLWXWLYDPHQWHGHUHODo}HVHQWUHRVLQGLYtGXRVQDTXHOHVHVWDGRVH RXWUDVFRLVDV$QDWXUH]DGHPXLWRVHVWDGRVPHQWDLVSRGHVHUFRQVWLWXWLYDPHQWH H[SOLFDGDVRPHQWHSRUUHIHUrQFLDDXPDPELHQWHPDLVDPSORRXVXEMHFWPDWWHU $VVLP FRPR FRUDo}HV H SODFDV HVWDGRV PHQWDLV FRQVWLWXWLYDPHQWH PDQWpP

(11)

QHQKXPD SDUWH GDV HVWUXWXUDV GRV SUySULRV HVWDGRV PHQWDLV HVWi IRUD GR LQGLYtGXR QR DPELHQWH PDLV DPSOR (VWDGRV PHQWDLV QmR VmR HOHV SUySULRV UHODo}HVFRPRDPELHQWH$HVWUXWXUDGRVHVWDGRVPHQWDLVLQFOXLDHVWUXWXUDV GH VHXV FRQWH~GRV UHSUHVHQWDFLRQDLV (VVDV FDUDFWHUtVWLFDV HVWUXWXUDLV QmR VmR DSHQDV FRQVWLWXWLYDV (ODV VmR DVSHFWRV ´SDUWHVµGD QDWXUH]D GRV HVWDGRV 2 FRQWH~GR UHSUHVHQWDFLRQDO GH XPD FUHQoD H VHXV HOHPHQWRV HVWUXWXUDLV VmR DVSHFWRV GD QDWXUH]D GD FUHQoD HP DFUpVFLPR DR VHU GD FUHQoD XPD FUHQoD FRPR RSRVWD D HVSHUDQoD RX VXSRVLomR (OHV VmR SDUWH GR TXH p VHU XP HVWDGR PHQWDO ([SOLFDomR SVLFROyJLFD ID] XVR H[SOLFDWLYR GHVVDV HVWUXWXUDV $QWLLQGLYLGXDOLVPRpFRPSDWtYHOFRPYiULDVSRVLo}HVDUHVSHLWRGRSUREOHPD PHQWHFRUSR&HUWDPHQWHHVWDGRVPHQWDLVQmRÁXWXDPOLYUHGHHVWDGRVItVLFRV XQGHUO\LQJ(OHVHVWmRORFDOL]DGRVRQGHRLQGLYtGXRTXHWHPHVWHVHVWDGRVHVWi

Seu lociHPWUDQVDo}HVFDXVDLVHVWmRRQGHRVHQVRFRPXPHDSVLFRORJLDHPStULFD

FRQVLGHUDTXHHOHVHVWmR$QDORJLDVFRPFRUDo}HVHSODFDVWHFW{QLFDVYDOHPDSHQD QRYDPHQWHPDQWHUHPPHQWH2IDWRGHTXHHVVDVHVSpFLHVFRQVWLWXWLYDPHQWH GHSHQGDP GH UHODo}HV FRP HQWLGDGHV DOpP GH VHXV OLPLWHV p FRPSOHWDPHQWH FRPSDWtYHO FRP FRUDo}HV H SODFDV WHFW{QLFDV HVWDUHP ORFDOL]DGRV QR HVSDoR (OHVQmRHVWmRORFDOL]DGRVRQGHDVUHODo}HVRXDVRXWUDVHQWLGDGHVFRPDVTXDLV HOHVHVWmRFRQVWLWXWLYDPHQWHUHODFLRQDGRVHVWmR$QWLLQGLYLGXDOLVPRWDOFRPR DSOLFDGRDHVWDGRVPHQWDLVHPStULFRVTXHVmRFRPRDVHQWLGDGHVItVLFDVGHIHQGH TXHWDLVHVWDGRVFRQVWLWXWLYDPHQWHQmRSRGHULDPVHUGDHVSpFLHTXHHOHVVmRVH UHODo}HVFDXVDLVHVSHFtÀFDVQmRVHPDQWLYHVVHPHQWUHRDPELHQWHHRLQGLYtGXR TXHHVWiQHVWHVWLSRVGHHVWDGRV%85*(S

$SHVDU GDV FUtWLFDV D WRGDV DV IRUPDV GH LQWHUQDOLVPR H LQGLYLGXDOLVPR DV TXDLV DSDUHFHP FODUDPHQWH QD LQWHUSUHWDomR GR SHQVDPHQWR GH 3XWQDP 7\OHU %XUJHFRQWUDULDPHQWHDRTXHVHSRVVDLQLFLDOPHQWHHVSHUDUQmRGHIHQGHQHPTXHRV VLJQLÀFDGRVHVWmRIRUDGDFDEHoDQHPPXLWRPHQRVTXHRVHVWDGRVPHQWDLVHVWHMDP IRUDGDFDEHoD(LVVRHOHSUySULRIRFDOL]DOLWHUDOPHQWHQROLYURPHVPROLYUR

2DQWLLQGLYLGXDOLVPRSHUVHQmRUHLYLQGLFDTXHRVHVWDGRVPHQWDLVVmRUHODo}HV FRPRDPELHQWHRXTXHRVHVWDGRVPHQWDLVQmRHVWmRQDFDEHoDRXTXHHQWLGDGHV QRDPELHQWHVmRSDUWHGRHVWDGRPHQWDORXGRFRQWH~GRUHSUHVHQWDFLRQDOGRV HVWDGRV(XUHMHLWRHVVDVDOHJDo}HV(VSpFLHVHVWDGRPHQWDOIXQGDPH[SOLFDo}HV SVLFROyJLFDV$PDLRULDGDVUHODo}HVFRQVWLWXWLYDVHQWUHRLQGLYtGXRHRDPELHQWH QmRVmRHVSpFLHVTXHVmRFLWDGDVHPH[SOLFDo}HVSVLFROyJLFDVRXRXWUDVH[SOLFDo}HV FLHQWtÀFDV$LQGDHOHVVmRUHOHYDQWHVSDUDXPDH[SOLFDomRFRQVWLWXWLYDGHXP LQGLYtGXRHVWDUHPXPHVSHFtÀFRHVWDGRSVLFROyJLFR

(12)

DUJXPHQWRX FRP VXFHVVR ² LPSOLFD TXH HVWDGRV RX HYHQWRV PDUFDGRV SRU FRQWH~GRUHSUHVHQWDFLRQDOQmRSRVVDPHVWDUQDFDEHoD%85*(S

$ SDUWLU GDV UHÁH[}HV DQWHULRUHV VREUH R ([WHUQDOLVPR 6RFLDO GH 7\OHU %XUJHHXJRVWDULDGHFKDPDUDDWHQomRSDUDGRLVDVSHFWRVRVTXDLVTXHPHSDUHFHP IXQGDPHQWDLV 3ULPHLUR R ÀOyVRIR WUDWD IXQGDPHQWDOPHQWH GRV FRQWH~GRV GD PHQWH H QmR GD VXD IRUPD RX VHMD HOH GHIHQGHULD TXH D DWLYLGDGH SHQVDQWH p SUySULDGRVXMHLWRDLQGDTXHRVVHXVFRQWH~GRVGHSHQGDPGRDPELHQWHItVLFR HOLQJXtVWLFR6HJXQGRHPERUDDVXDGHÀQLomRGHSHQVDPHQWRQmRLQFOXDWRGR R FRQMXQWR GH DWLYLGDGHV PHQWDLV LVVR QmR VLJQLÀFD TXH D VXD FRQFHSomR GH PHQWH H[FOXD DVSHFWRV SXUDPHQWH LQWHUQRV Mi TXH FRPR YLPRV SUHVHUYDPVH WDQWRDVH[SHULrQFLDVVXEMHWLYDVTXDOLWDWLYDVUHODFLRQDGDVDRPXQGRH[WHUQRTXHU GL]HUDVYiULDVIRUPDVGHSHUFHSomRVHQVtYHOTXDQWRDVH[SHULrQFLDVTXDOLWDWLYDV FRQFHELGDVFRPRSXUDPHQWHVXEMHWLYDVWDLVFRPRGRUHVHVHQWLPHQWRVHPJHUDO

3DUD GHVHQYROYHU HVVHV DVSHFWRV H FRP EDVH QHOHV WHFHU DOJXPDV FRQVLGHUDo}HVDUHVSHLWRGRVOLPLWHVGR([WHUQDOLVPR6RFLDOSDUDRHQIUHQWDPHQWR GRV SUREOHPDV GD QDWXUH]D GD PHQWH H GD UHODomR PHQWH WUDWDUHL D VHJXLU GR SHQVDPHQWR GD ÀOyVRID /\QQH %DNHU FXMDV LGHLDV FRPR VXEOLQKDPRV IRUDP EDVWDQWHLQÁXHQFLDGDVSRU7\OHU%XUJH

3 O ANTI-INDIVIDUALISMO DE LYNNE BAKER

(13)

LQFOXtVVHDOJXPDVH[SHULrQFLDVVXEMHWLYDVTXDOLWDWLYDVWDLVFRPRDOHJULDWULVWH]D GRUHWF&RQWXGRFRPRYHUHPRVSRVWHULRUPHQWHHVVDQmRpXPDTXHVWmRPXLWR VLPSOHV SRLV GH DFRUGR FRP R H[WHUQDOLVPR VRFLDO WDLV H[SHULrQFLDV QmR VmR FDUDFWHUL]DGDVFRPRWLSRVGHSHQVDPHQWRVRVTXDLVVmRGHVFULWRVHPWHUPRVGH DWLWXGHVSURSRVLFLRQDLV'HL[DQGRSURYLVRULDPHQWHHVVDTXHVWmRHPDEHUWRSDVVR DJRUDjDQiOLVHGDGHÀQLomRGHH[WHUQDOLVPRVRFLDOH[SRVWDSRU/\QQH%DNHUQR

mesmo artigo.

&RPR YLPRV DQWHULRUPHQWH R H[WHUQDOLVPR p DSUHVHQWDGR FRPR XPD FRQFHSomR VHJXQGR D TXDO RV FRQWH~GRV GH SHQVDPHQWR GH XPD SHVVRD VmR GHWHUPLQDGRVSHORVHXDPELHQWH1HVVHVWHUPRVDTXHVWmRIXQGDPHQWDOSDVVDD VHUDVHJXLQWHIRUPXODGDSRU/\QQH%DNHUGHWUrVPDQHLUDVGLVWLQWDVFRPR´>@DV FDUDFWHUtVWLFDVGRDPELHQWHSRGHPFRQWULEXLUSDUDRFRQWH~GRGRSHQVDPHQWRGH XPDSHVVRDµ"%$.(5ES´>@FRPRRVFRQWH~GRVGHSHQVDPHQWR VmRLQGLYLGXDGRVµ"%$.(5ESTXDLV´>@VmRDVFRQGLo}HVVREDV TXDLVXPDSHVVRDtemXPSHQVDPHQWRFRPXPFRQWH~GRSDUWLFXODU"µ%$.(5

ES2HOHPHQWRFRPXPGHVVDVWUrVTXHVW}HVpDEXVFDSHODVFRQGLo}HV UHVSRQViYHLVSHORFRQWH~GRHVSHFtÀFRGHFDGDSHQVDPHQWRRXVHMDRTXHID] FRPTXHXPSHQVDPHQWRVHMDGLIHUHQWHGHRXWURSHQVDPHQWRRXRTXHGHWHUPLQD DVXD´LGHQWLGDGHµWHUPRXVDGRSHODÀOyVRIDFRPRYHUHPRVDVHJXLU

$UHVSRVWDDHVVDVTXHVW}HVDGYpPGHXPDDERUGDJHPWHyULFDDTXDO/\QQH %DNHUFKDPDGH([WHUQDOLVPR6RFLDOSRUHODGHÀQLGDQRVVHJXLQWHVWHUPRV´$ PDLRULDGRVFRQWH~GRVGHSHQVDPHQWRGHXPDSHVVRDpGHWHUPLQDGDHPSDUWH SHODVSUiWLFDVVRFLDLVHOLQJtVWLFDVGDFRPXQLGDGHGDSHVVRDµ%$.(5E S 2EVHUYHPRV QRYDPHQWH TXH D ÀOyVRID XVD DV H[SUHVV}HV ´PDLRULDµ H ´HP SDUWHµ D FXMDV GLÀFXOGDGHV Mi QRV UHIHULPRV 2 TXH JRVWDULD GH UHVVDOWDU SULPHLUDPHQWH QHVVD GHÀQLomR GH ([WHUQDOLVPR 6RFLDO p R IDWR GH TXH R DPELHQWHWLGRSRUIXQGDPHQWDOSDUDRFRQWH~GRGRSHQVDPHQWRGHXPDSHVVRD pRDPELHQWHVRFLRFXOWXUDOQRTXDOHODHVWiLQVHULGDpDSUiWLFDOLQJXtVWLFDGHVXD FRPXQLGDGH7DOSUiWLFDFRPRYHUHPRVID]DPHGLDomRFRPRXWURDPELHQWHQR TXDOWRGDSHVVRDHVWiLPHUVDLVWRpRDPELHQWHQDWXUDO&RPRSURFXUDUHLPRVWUDU R ([WHUQDOLVPR 6RFLDO HVWDEHOHFH XPD UHODomR LQGLVVRFLiYHO HQWUH SHQVDPHQWR OLQJXDJHP H QDWXUH]D SULYLOHJLDQGR FRQVLGHUDYHOPHQWH D OLQJXDJHP 9HMDPRV FRPRHVVDUHODomRpDSUHVHQWDGDSRU/\QQH%DNHU7UDWDUHLLQLFLDOPHQWHGDUHODomR HQWUHSHQVDPHQWRHOLQJXDJHP$VHJXLUIRFDOL]DUHLDUHODomRHQWUHOLQJXDJHP SHQVDPHQWRHDPELHQWHFXOWXUDO3RUÀPIRFDUHLQDUHODomRHQWUHSHQVDPHQWR

(14)

$UHODomRHQWUHSHQVDPHQWRHOLQJXDJHPpFRPRVHSRGHREVHUYDUQD FLWDomRDVHJXLU_{XPDUHODomRLQWUtQVHFDRXVHMDSHQVDPHQWRHOLQJXDJHPHVWmR}

intimamente ligados.

$ LGHQWLGDGH GH XP SHQVDPHQWR GHSHQGH GD LGHQWLGDGH GH VHX FRQWH~GR SURSRVLFLRQDO >@ (X XVDUHL D SDODYUD ´FRQFHLWRµ SDUD UHIHULU DRV LWHQV FRQVWLWXWLYRVGRVFRQWH~GRVSURSRVLFLRQDLVHHXXVDUHLDSDODYUD´SHQVDPHQWRVµ SDUD TXDOTXHU HVWDGR PHQWDO FRP FRQWH~GR SURSRVLFLRQDO SRU H[HPSOR FUHQoDVGHVHMRVLQWHQo}HVHVSHUDQoDVPHGRVHWF(XGLUHLTXHSHQVDPHQWRV FRQWrPRXVmRFRPSRVWRVSRUFRQFHLWRV%$.(5ES

3DUDPHOKRUHQWHQGHUDHQXQFLDGDUHODomRHQWUHSHQVDPHQWRHOLQJXDJHP WUrVDVSHFWRVGHYHPVHUFRQVLGHUDGRV$SDUWLUGDVFLWDo}HVDQWHULRUHVH[DPLQDUHL DGHÀQLomRGHSHQVDPHQWRDVHJXLUDGHÀQLomRGHFRQFHLWRHSRUÀPDUHODomR SHQVDPHQWRHFRQFHLWR4XDQWRjGHÀQLomRGHSHQVDPHQWRWUrVDVSHFWRVPHSDUHFHP UHOHYDQWHV3ULPHLURRTXHVLJQLÀFDGL]HUTXHD´>@LGHQWLGDGHGRSHQVDPHQWR GHSHQGHGDLGHQWLGDGHGHVHXFRQWH~GRSURSRVLFLRQDOµ"6HULDRPHVPRTXHGL]HU TXHRFRQWH~GRGRSHQVDPHQWRGHSHQGHGRFRQWH~GRSURSRVLFLRQDO"2EVHUYHPRV TXHDRDSUHVHQWDUFRPRH[HPSORVGHFRQWH~GRSURSRVLFLRQDODVFUHQoDVRVGHVHMRV DVLQWHQo}HVHWF/\QQH%DNHUQmRGLIHUHQFLDDQRomRGH´FRQWH~GRSURSRVLFLRQDOµ GDQRomRGH´DWLWXGHSURSRVLFLRQDOµRTXHHQWHQGRVHULPSRUWDQWHSDUDVHSHQVDU QDGLIHUHQoDHQWUHPRGRV²DWLWXGHV²HRVSUySULRVFRQWH~GRVGRSHQVDPHQWR(VVD GLIHUHQoDSDUHFHHVWDULPSOtFLWDQRSUySULRWH[WRGDÀOyVRIDTXDQGRHODVHUHIHUH DRV FRQFHLWRV FRPR RV ´>@ LWHQV FRQVWLWXWLYRV GRV FRQWH~GRV SURSRVLFLRQDLVµ 6HQGRRFDVRSDUHFHQmRKDYHUSUREOHPDHPUHVSRQGHUjVTXHVW}HVFRORFDGDVQR LQtFLRGHVWHSDUiJUDIRFRPDLQWHUSUHWDomRGHTXHRSHQVDPHQWRHPVXDIRUPDH FRQWH~GRGHSHQGHGDIRUPDHFRQWH~GRSURSRVLFLRQDLV

2 VHJXQGR DVSHFWR p R TXH WUDWD GD UHODomR HQWUH R SHQVDPHQWR FDUDFWHUL]DGRFRPRXPHVWDGRPHQWDOHRFRQWH~GRSURSRVLFLRQDO$RUHVVDOYDU TXHXVDDSDODYUD´SHQVDPHQWRµSDUDVHUHIHULUD´>@TXDOTXHUHVWDGRPHQWDO FRP FRQWH~GR SURSRVLFLRQDOµ HVWDULD /\QQH %DNHU GHIHQGHQGR TXH H[LVWHP HVWDGRVPHQWDLVTXHQmRWrPFRQWH~GRSURSRVLFLRQDOHTXHSRUWDQWRQmRVmR

_{$UHODomRHQWUHSHQVDPHQWRHOLQJXDJHPpH[SRVWDQRVPHVPRVWHUPRVQRWH[WR´)LUVW3HUVRQ}

(15)

SHQVDPHQWRV"6HIRURFDVRTXDLVVHULDPHVVHVHVWDGRVPHQWDLV"&RPRH[HPSORV GHSHQVDPHQWR/\QQH%DNHUFLWDFRPRYLPRVDVFUHQoDVRVGHVHMRVDVLQWHQo}HV DVHVSHUDQoDVRVPHGRVHWF4XDOVHULDRHVWDWXWRSRUH[HPSORGDVSHUFHSo}HV H VHQWLPHQWRV FRPR DOHJULD WULVWH]D H GRU Mi UHIHULGRV DQWHULRUPHQWH" 6HULDP HYHQWRV PHQWDLV PDV QmR SHQVDPHQWRV RX VHMD HVWDGRV LUUHGXWtYHLV DR ItVLFR PDVFRQIRUPHRVWHUPRVGDÀOyVRIDVHPFRQWH~GRSURSRVLFLRQDO"9HMDPRVVHp SRVVtYHOH[SOLFLWDUHVVHSRQWRFRPEDVHQDGHÀQLomRGH´FRQFHLWRµHGHVXDUHODomR FRPRSHQVDPHQWRSURSRVWRVSRU/\QQH%DNHUWHUFHLURDVSHFWRGDUHODomRHQWUH SHQVDPHQWRHOLQJXDJHPDVHUFRQVLGHUDGR

2VFRQFHLWRVVmRDSUHVHQWDGRVFRPRRVFRQVWLWXLQWHVIXQGDPHQWDLVGR SHQVDPHQWR -i QRWDPRV TXH RV FRQFHLWRV VmR GHÀQLGRV FRPR RV ´LWHQVµ TXH FRQVWLWXHPRVFRQWH~GRVSURSRVLFLRQDLVHFRQVHTXHQWHPHQWH²FRQVLGHUDQGRVH TXH´>@DLGHQWLGDGHGHXPSHQVDPHQWRGHSHQGHGDLGHQWLGDGHGHVHXFRQWH~GR SURSRVLFLRQDOµ²RVFRQFHLWRVFRQVWLWXHPRFRQWH~GRGRVSHQVDPHQWRV3RUpP DÀUPDUTXHRFRQFHLWRpR´LWHPµFRQVWLWXWLYRGRSHQVDPHQWRQmRpGL]HUWXGRR TXHpUHOHYDQWHDVHXUHVSHLWRLVWRpWHQGRHPYLVWDDVXDUHODomRFRPRFRQWH~GR GR SHQVDPHQWR GHYHVH H[SOLFDU DV FRQGLo}HV GHWHUPLQDQWHV GH VXD SRVVH H FRQWH~GRDVTXDLVFRPRYHUHPRVDVHJXLUHQYROYHPRDPELHQWHVRFLRFXOWXUDO

$ HVVH UHVSHLWR /\QQH %DNHU HQIDWL]D TXH R TXH ´>@ p VLJQLÀFDQWH D UHVSHLWRGRVFRQFHLWRVDOpPGRIDWRGHTXHHOHVFRPS}HPSHQVDPHQWRVpTXH HOHVWrPFRQGLo}HVGHDSOLFDomRGHÀQLWLYDPHQWHXPFRQFHLWRDSOLFDVHDDOJXPDV FRLVDVHGHÀQLWLYDPHQWHQmRVHDSOLFDDRXWUDVFRLVDVµ%$.(5ES $HVVHUHVSHLWRFRQIRUPH/\QQH%DNHUWHUXPFRQFHLWRpVHUFDSD]GHDSOLFiOR FRUUHWDPHQWHHPXPDDPSODYDULHGDGHGHFDVRVDLQGDTXHHPDOJXQVGHVVHVFDVRV RFRQKHFLPHQWRGDVFRQGLo}HVGHDSOLFDomRVHMDSDUFLDO(VVDWHVHpH[SOLFDGD H MXVWLÀFDGD QR FRQWH[WR GD DERUGDJHP H[WHUQDOLVWD VRFLDO VHQGR LQLFLDOPHQWH DSUHVHQWDGDHVTXHPDWLFDPHQWHSHODÀOyVRIDQRVVHJXLQWHVWHUPRV´3DUDTXDOTXHU 6VH6WHP&>RFRQFHLWR&@VHJXHVHTXHPDQWHQGRVHFRQVWDQWHVDKLVWyULDItVLFD HRVHVWDGRVLQWHUQRVItVLFRVGH6VH6HVWLYHVVHHPXPDFRPXQLGDGHFRPSUiWLFDV VRFLDLVHOLQJtVWLFDVUHOHYDQWHPHQWHGLIHUHQWHV6QmRWHULD&>@VHDOJXpPWHPRX QmRXPFRQFHLWR&GHSHQGHGDVSUiWLFDVVRFLDLVHOLQJtVWLFDVGHVXDFRPXQLGDGHµ %$.(5ES2XGHIRUPDPDLVDEUDQJHQWH

(16)

6HFDSD]GHDSOLFDU&FRUUHWDPHQWHHPXPVLJQLÀFDQWHQXPHURGHFDVRVHLL 6WHPDOJXPDWDOYH]SDUFLDOFRPSUHHQVmRGDVFRQGLo}HVHFRQVHTrQFLDVGD DSOLFDomRGH&%$.(5DS

9HPRVDVVLPTXHDVSUiWLFDVOLQJXtVWLFDVHVRFLDLVVHULDPRVGHWHUPLQDQWHV SDUDDSRVVHRXQmRGHXPFRQFHLWRHHVVDWHVHQmRVHUHVWULQJHFRPRVHSRGHULD SHQVDU j SULPHLUD YLVWD DSHQDV DR TXH FKDPDUHPRV GH FRQFHLWRV GH ´HVSpFLH FXOWXUDOµRXVHMDRVFRQFHLWRVVRFLDLVSROtWLFRVRXOHJDLVPDVWDPEpPDRTXHRV ÀOyVRIRVFKDPDPGHFRQFHLWRVGH´HVSpFLHQDWXUDOµ3URFXUDUHLLOXVWUDUHVVDWHVH HDSRQWDUDOJXPDVGHVXDVGLÀFXOGDGHVDSDUWLUGDDSUHVHQWDomRVXFLQWDGHDOJXQV GHQWUHRVH[HPSORVSURSRVWRVSRU/\QQH%DNHU&RPHoDUHLSRUXPFRQFHLWRGH HVSpFLHQDWXUDO_{, o conceito de rocha.}

6XSRQKDPRV TXH XP VXMHLWR ´$µ DFUHGLWH TXH URFKDV VmR SHVDGDV H TXH´$µH[SUHVVHDVXDFUHQoDHPSRUWXJXrVQRFRQWH[WRGHVXDFRPXQLGDGH OLQJXtVWLFD ´;µ GL]HQGR ´5RFKDV VmR SHVDGDVµ 6XSRQKDPRV WDPEpP TXH H[LVWDRXWUDFRPXQLGDGHOLQJXtVWLFD´<µTXHWHQKDXPDSDODYUDIRQRORJLFDPHQWH LQGLVWLQJXtYHOGDSDODYUDÚRFKDµSURQXQFLDGDSRU´$µQDFRPXQLGDGHOLQJXtVWLFD ´;µ FRP D GLIHUHQoD GH TXH QD FRPXQLGDGH OLQJXtVWLFD ´<µ D SDODYUD ´>@ LQFOXL VRPHQWH SHGUDV JUDQGHV HQFRQWUDGDV HP WHUUDV VHFDV HP FDPSRV RX PRQWDQKDVHQmRSHGUDVJUDQGHVHQFRQWUDGDVSHUWRGHRXHPOHLWRVGHiJXDµ %$.(5ES$WHVHGRH[WHUQDOLVPRVRFLDOpTXHVH´$µSURIHUHD SDODYUDÚRFKDµQDVGXDVFRPXQLGDGHVOLQJXtVWLFDV´$µQmRFRPHWHULDXPHUUR FRQFHLWXDOQDFRPXQLGDGHOLQJXtVWLFD´;µPDVVHIRVVHWUD]LGRUHSHQWLQDPHQWH SDUDDFRPXQLGDGHOLQJXtVWLFD´<µHDtXWLOL]DVVHDSDODYUDTXHVRDFRPRÚRFKDµ ² VHP TXH WLYHVVH WHPSR SRUWDQWR SDUD DSUHHQGHU D GLIHUHQoD HQWUH DV GXDV SDODYUDVQDVGXDVGLIHUHQWHVFRPXQLGDGHV²´$µFRPHWHULDXPHUURFRQFHLWXDO QDFRPXQLGDGHOLQJXtVWLFD´<µ$OpPGLVVRHSRUFDXVDGLVVRQDFRPXQLGDGH OLQJXtVWLFD´;µ´$µWHULDDFUHQoD´5RFKDVVmRSHVDGDVµPDVQmRWHULDDPHVPD FUHQoDQDFRPXQLGDGH´<µ(DGLIHUHQoDHQWUHDVGXDVVHQWHQoDVDTXDOGDULDD HODVYDORUHVGHYHUGDGHGLVWLQWRVQmRHVWDULDQRVUHVSHFWLYRVVRQVSURIHULGRVRV TXDLVFRPRYLPRVVHULDPLGrQWLFRVPDVVLPHPVXDVUHIHUrQFLDVGLVWLQWDVHP VXDVGLIHUHQWHVFRQGLo}HVGHDSOLFDomR_{'HVVHPRGRSUHVHUYDQGRVHDPHVPD}

KLVWyULD ItVLFD H D PHVPD RUJDQL]DomR H FRQVWLWXLomR FRUSRUDOFHUHEUDO GH ´$µ QRSURIHULPHQWRGDPHVPDSDODYUD²VRQRUDPHQWHIDODQGR²QDVFRPXQLGDGHV ´;µ H ´<µ $ WHULD GLIHUHQWHV FUHQoDV $ÀQDO RV FRQFHLWRV VHULDP GLIHUHQWHV

_{$SUHVHQWRRH[HPSORUHIHULQGRPHjOtQJXDSRUWXJXHVDDRLQYpVGDOtQJXDLQJOHVDFLWDGDSHODÀOyVRID}

_{3RGHVHFRQFHEHUIDFLOPHQWHTXHQRkPELWRGHXPDPHVPDFRPXQLGDGHOLQJXtVWLFDSRVVDKDYHU}

(17)

´2VFRQFHLWRVH[SUHVVRVGHVVHPRGRGLIHUHPQDVGXDVFRPXQLGDGHVµ%$.(5 ES'RTXHIRLH[SRVWRDQWHULRUPHQWHSRGHVHFRQFOXLUTXHVH´$µ IRVVH FULDGR QD FRPXQLGDGH OLQJXtVWLFD ´<µ QD TXDO WHULD DSUHQGLGR D XVDU D SDODYUDIRQRORJLFDPHQWHLQGLVWLQJXtYHOGDSDODYUD´URFKDµDRXViODREHGHFHQGR jV´FRQGLo}HVGHDSOLFDomRµ´$µQmRHVWDULDFRPHWHQGRQHQKXPHUURFRQFHLWXDO 3UHVHUYDUVHLD GHVVH PRGR R YDORU GH YHUGDGH GH VXD FUHQoD ´5RFKDV VmR SHVDGDVµ 0RUDO GD KLVWyULD VHQWHQoDV IRQROyJLFD H VLQWDWLFDPHQWH LGrQWLFDV SRGHPH[SUHVVDUGLIHUHQWHVFUHQoDV

2 FRQFHLWR XWLOL]DGR QR H[HPSOR DQWHULRU SRGH VHU WRPDGR FRPR XP FRQFHLWRGHHVSpFLHFXOWXUDODLQGDTXHVHJXQGR/\QQH%DNHULQWXLWLYDPHQWHQmR R VHMD (QWHQGR TXH QmR p R FDVR QR PRPHQWR SRU QmR VHU UHOHYDQWH SDUD D TXHVWmRTXHFRQVLGHURFHQWUDOGLVFXWLUHPTXHPHGLGDRH[HPSORSURSRVWRpGH HVSpFLHFXOWXUDORXGHHVSpFLHQDWXUDO$ÀQDODÀOyVRIDGHIHQGHFRPRYHUHPRV TXHWRGRVRVFRQFHLWRVVmRGHFHUWRPRGRGHHVSpFLHFXOWXUDO(QIRFRDVHJXLU XPH[HPSORFRVWXPHLUDPHQWHFLWDGRFRPRVHQGRGHHVSpFLHQDWXUDO/HPEURTXH HVWRXDSUHVHQWDQGRRH[HPSORGH/\QQH%DNHUFRPFHUWDOLEHUGDGHGHVRUWHTXH PHSHUPLWDH[SULPLUPDLVFODUDPHQWHDPDQHLUDFRPRRFRPSUHHQGR7UDWDVHGH HQWHQGHUDSDUWLUGRH[WHUQDOLVPRVRFLDORVFRQFHLWRV´OLPHVWRQHµH´VDQGVWRQHµ RVTXDLVWUDGX]LUHLUHVSHFWLYDPHQWHSRU´FDOFiULRµH´DUHQLWRµ$SHQDVSDUDTXH RH[HPSORSRVVDVHUYLUDRSURSyVLWRGHLOXVWUDUDDERUGDJHPH[WHUQDOLVWDVRFLDO GDPHQWHVXSRQKDPRVTXHFDOFiULRHDUHQLWRWHQKDPDPERVXPDFRUDPDUHODGD HVHMDPWDPEpPÀVLFDPHQWHLGrQWLFRVHPRXWUDVFDUDFWHUtVWLFDVPDFURItVLFDVGH WDOPDQHLUDTXHRREVHUYDGRUFRPXPQmRFRQVLJDGLVWLQJXLORVSHODYLVmRQDWXUDO PDVTXHVHMDPTXLPLFDPHQWHGLVWLQWRVRXVHMDTXHFDOFiULRVHMDFDUERQDWRGH FiOFLR&D&2HTXHDUHQLWRVHMDGLy[LGRGHVLOLFRQH6L2

&RQVLGHUDUHLDJRUDGXDVVLWXDo}HVGLVWLQWDV3ULPHLUDVLWXDomRXPVXMHLWR´$µ IRLFULDGRHYLYHQDFRPXQLGDGHOLQJXtVWLFD´;µ´$µIDODDOtQJXDGHVVDFRPXQLGDGH QD TXDO H[LVWH FDOFiULR PDV QmR DUHQLWR (PERUD QXQFD WHQKD YLVWR FDOFiULR SHVVRDOPHQWH´$µFRQKHFHWXGRDUHVSHLWRGHVXDVSURSULHGDGHVPDFURItVLFDV² QmRFRQKHFHSRUWDQWRDVVXDVSURSULHGDGHVTXtPLFDV$GTXLULXHVVHFRQKHFLPHQWR SRUPHLRGRVOLYURVHGRVFROHJDVGHHVFROD$VVLP´$µWHPRFRQFHLWRFDOFiULR LVWRp´$µ´>@pFDSD]GHDSOLFDUFRUUHWDPHQWHRFRQFHLWRFDOFiULRH¶$·´WHP XPDFRPSUHHQVmRWDOYH]SDUFLDO>MiTXHQmRWHPRFRQKHFLPHQWRGDFRPSRVLomR TXtPLFD@GDVFRQGLo}HVGHDSOLFDomRGHFDOFiULRµ%$.(5ES

(18)

GRVFROHJDVGHHVFROD$VVLP´$µWHPRFRQFHLWRDUHQLWRRXVHMD´$µ´pFDSD] GHDSOLFDUFRUUHWDPHQWHRFRQFHLWRDUHQLWRH´$µ´>@WHPXPDFRPSUHHQVmR WDOYH] SDUFLDO >Mi TXH QmR WHP R FRQKHFLPHQWR GD FRPSRVLomR TXtPLFD@ GDV FRQGLo}HVGHDSOLFDomRGHDUHQLWRµ%$.(5ES

,PDJLQHVHDJRUDRVHJXLQWHDFRPXQLGDGHOLQJXtVWLFD´<µpXPDFySLD LGrQWLFDGDFRPXQLGDGHOLQJXtVWLFD´;µWDQWRHPUHODomRjVSHVVRDVH[LVWHQWHV VXDKLVWyULDItVLFDHFXOWXUDOTXDQWRHPUHODomRjDSDUrQFLDHFRQVWLWXLomRItVLFD GDPDWpULDHREMHWRVH[LVWHQWHVPDVFRPXPD~QLFDGLIHUHQoD²DH[LVWrQFLDGH DUHQLWR DR LQYpV GH FDOFiULR /HPEUHPRV TXH HVVD GLIHUHQoD H[LVWH DSHQDV QR QtYHO PLFURItVLFR FRQVWLWXLomR TXtPLFD QmR VHQGR SRUWDQWR LGHQWLÀFDGD SRU ´$µTXHFRQKHFHDUHQLWRDSHQDVSRUVXDVSURSULHGDGHVPDFURÀVLFDV3HQVHPRV WDPEpPTXHDSDODYUD´FDOFiULRµWHQKDXPDFySLDIRQRORJLFDPHQWHLGrQWLFDHP ´<µDTXDOpXWLOL]DGDSDUD´GHVLJQDUµDUHQLWR6HJXQGRRH[WHUQDOLVPRVRFLDO ´$µ QmR WHULD HP ´<µ R FRQFHLWR ´FDOFiULRµ H VLP R FRQFHLWR ´DUHQLWRµ 8PD SDODYUDIRQRORJLFDPHQWHLGrQWLFDWHULDUHIHUrQFLDGLVWLQWDQDVGXDVFRPXQLGDGHV $FRQFOXVmRFRQIRUPHRVWHUPRVGH/\QQH%DNHUpDVHJXLQWH

O conceito *calcário* é um conceito diferente do conceito *arenito*. Os

GRLVFRQFHLWRVWrPFRQGLo}HVGHDSOLFDomRLQWHLUDPHQWHGLIHUHQWHV9DULDQGR VRPHQWH D FRPXQLGDGH GH $ QyV SRGHPRV YDULDU R FRQFHLWR TXH $ WHP

*calcário * ou *arenito* sem mudar nenhum de seus estados internos ou

QHQKXPDGDVSHVVRDVRXFRLVDVFRPDVTXDLVHOHLQWHUDJHRXTXDLVTXHUGDV PDQHLUDVQmRLQWHQFLRQDLVFRPDVTXDLVHOHLQWHUDJH$QHPPHVPRWHPIDOVDV FUHQoDV VREUH DV FRQGLo}HV GH DSOLFDomR GH XP RX GH RXWUR GRV FRQFHLWRV FDOFiULRRXDUHQLWRHOHQmRWHPIDOVDVFUHQoDVDUHVSHLWRGDFRPSRVLomR TXtPLFDGHFDGDXPGHOHVGHVGHTXHHOHQmRWHPFUHQoDVVREUHFRPSRVLomR TXtPLFD²QmRPDLVGRTXHQRVVRVDQFHVWUDLVRVTXDLVWLQKDPRFRQFHLWRGH FDOFiULR%$.(5ES

(19)

/\QQH%DNHUSURS}HGXDVUHVSRVWDVDHVVDREMHomR3ULPHLUDUHVSRVWDD ÀOyVRIDVDOLHQWDTXHQRH[SHULPHQWRGHSHQVDPHQWRWDOFRPRIRLDSUHVHQWDGR LQLFLDOPHQWH´$µDGTXLULXRVFRQFHLWRVGHFDOFiULRHDUHQLWRQDVSUiWLFDVVRFLDLV HOLQJXtVWLFDVRXVHMDDWUDYpVGRVOLYURVHGRVFROHJDVGDHVFRODQmRWHQGRWLGR TXDOTXHUWLSRGHLQWHUDomRGLUHWDFRPFDOFiULRHDUHQLWR(VVDUHVSRVWDPHSDUHFH LQVDWLVIDWyULDSRLVDLQGDTXHQDVLWXDomRSDUWLFXODUHVERoDGDSRVVDPRVFRQVLGHUDU TXH´$µQmRWHQKDLQWHUDJLGRGLUHWDPHQWHFRPWDLVHOHPHQWRVGDQDWXUH]DQDGD LPSHGH TXH RXWURV VXMHLWRV SRU H[HPSOR DTXHOHV TXH SURGX]LUDP RV OLYURV FRQVXOWDGRVSRU´$µWHQKDPWLGRHVVDLQWHUDomR3RGHUtDPRVVXEOLQKDUTXHVH HVVHIRVVHRFDVRRVFRQFHLWRV´FDOFiULRµH´DUHQLWRµVHULDPGH´HVSpFLHQDWXUDOµ HQmRGH´HVSpFLHFXOWXUDOµ"1mRpRTXHSHQVD/\QQH%DNHU$DXWRUDDÀUPD FRPRVHJXQGDUHVSRVWDjREMHomRH[WHUQDOLVWDQDWXUDOLVWDTXH´>@DH[LVWrQFLDGH DPRVWUDVGHHVSpFLHQDWXUDOQmRpnuncaVXÀFLHQWHSDUDDOJXpPWHURFRQFHLWRGD

HVSpFLH3UiWLFDVVRFLDLVHOLQJXtVWLFDVVmRRVLQWHUPHGLiULRVUHTXHULGRVSDUDTXHVH FRPSDUWLOKHPRVFRQFHLWRVHPTXDOTXHUVLWXDomRµ%$.(5ES'H DFRUGRFRPDÀOyVRIDVHSRUXPODGRDVSUiWLFDVVRFLDLVHOLQJXtVWLFDVLQFOXHP DVFDUDFWHUtVWLFDVGRDPELHQWHDRVTXDLVHODVVHUHIHUHPHPVXDVFRQGLo}HVGH DSOLFDomRSRURXWURDPHUDH[LVWrQFLDGRVHOHPHQWRVQDWXUDLVFDOFiULRHDUHQLWRQD QDWXUH]DQmRVHULDVXÀFLHQWHSDUDDH[LVWrQFLDGRVFRQFHLWRV´FDOFiULRµH´DUHQLWRµ HPXPDFRPXQLGDGHTXHYLYHQHVVHDPELHQWH

eQHVVHPHVPRVHQWLGRTXH/\QQH%DNHULQWHUSUHWDRXWURH[HPSORRGR XVRGRVFRQFHLWRVGH´JROÀQKRµH´WXEDUmRµHUHIXWDREMHo}HVVHPHOKDQWHVjV DQWHULRUHV&RQWUDR([WHUQDOLVPR6RFLDOSRGHUVHLDDOHJDUTXHWHURXQmRWHU RVFRQFHLWRVGH´JROÀQKRµRXGH´WXEDUmRµGHSHQGHDSHQDVGDVGLIHUHQoDVHQWUH DVHVSpFLHVQDWXUDLVHQmRGHSUiWLFDVOLQJXtVWLFDV'HVVHPRGRVHXPDSHVVRD VROLWiULD²D´VROLWiULD-{µ²YLYHVVHQXPDLOKDFHUFDGDSRUWXEDU}HVHODWHULDR FRQFHLWR GH ´WXEDUmRµ H VH IRVVH FHUFDGD SRU JROÀQKRV HOD WHULD R FRQFHLWR GH´JROÀQKRµ&RQWUDHVVDWHVH/\QQH%DNHUGHIHQGHSULPHLUDPHQWHTXHHP JHUDODVSHVVRDVQmRDGTXLUHPHVVHVFRQFHLWRVDSDUWLUGDLQWHUDomRGLUHWDFRP JROÀQKRVRXWXEDU}HVHVLPGDVSUiWLFDVOLQJXtVWLFDVHVRFLDLVGHVXDFRPXQLGDGH $OpPGLVVRDH[LVWrQFLDGHDPRVWUDVGHHVSpFLHQDWXUDOQmRVHULDVXÀFLHQWHSDUD VHWHURFRQFHLWRGDTXHODHVSpFLHDS(PFRQVRQkQFLDFRPHVVDLGHLD D ÀOyVRID DÀUPD TXH D SHVVRD VROLWiULD QD LOKD QmR DGTXLULULD RV FRQFHLWRV GH ´WXEDUmRµRXGH´JROÀQKRµ/\QQH%DNHUDUJXPHQWDgrosso modoTXHD6ROLWiULD

(20)

RXVHMDHODQmRWHULDFRPRÀ[DUDH[WHQVmRGRFRQFHLWRRTXDOVHULDHVWDEHOHFLGR SHODFRPXQLGDGHOLQJXtVWLFD

1LQJXpP WHP XP FRQFHLWR D QmR VHU TXH KDMD XPD GLIHUHQoD HQWUH DSOLFiOR FRUUHWDPHQWH H DSOLFiOR LQFRUUHWDPHQWH 1D DXVrQFLD GH XPD FRPXQLGDGH QmRKiQDGDTXHSRVVDWRUQDUFRUUHWRDSOLFDURVXSRVWRFRQFHLWRGHWXEDUmR GD 6ROLWiULD -{ FRPR RSRVWR D WXEDU}HV FDEHoDGHPDUWHOR RX WXEDU}HVRX JROÀQKRV 1mR Ki QDGD QR DPELHQWH GD 6ROLWiULD -{ TXH WRUQDULD LQFRUUHWR DSOLFDUVHXVXSRVWRFRQFHLWRDJROÀQKRVRXLPSHGLODGHDSOLFiORDWXEDU}HV WLJUHGRPDU$SHQDVDIDPLOLDULGDGHGD6ROLWiULD-{FRPWXEDU}HVMXQWRFRP RXWUDVFULDWXUDVGRPDUGLÀFLOPHQWHGiDHODRFRQFHLWRGHWXEDUmR([LVWHP HVSpFLHVGHWXEDU}HVTXHVmRUDGLFDOPHQWHGHVVHPHOKDQWHVHQWUHVL>@(X FRQFRUGRTXHVHUXPPHPEURGHXPDGHWHUPLQDGDHVSpFLHQDWXUDOLQGHSHQGH GDVSUiWLFDVVRFLDLVHOLQJtVWLFDVPDVHVWHSRQWRHLUUHOHYDQWH$TXHVWmRQmRGL] UHVSHLWRDVHUXPPHPEURGHXPDHVSpFLHQDWXUDOHODGL]UHVSHLWRjDTXLVLomR GRFRQFHLWRGHXPDHVSpFLHQDWXUDOWXEDUmR2TXHÀ[DDH[WHQVmRGHXP VXSRVWRFRQFHLWRGHXPDSHVVRDHPLVRODPHQWRXPDSHVVRDVHPXPDOLQJXDJHP QDWXUDOFRPRRLQJOrV"1DDXVrQFLDGDOLQJXDJHPRTXHIDULDFRPTXHTXDOTXHU GRVHYHQWRVPHQWDLVRXYRFDOL]Do}HVGD6ROLWiULD-{H[SUHVVDVVHPRFRQFHLWR WXEDUmR FRPR RSRVWR D WXEDUmR FDEHoDGHPDUWHOR WXEDUmR WLJUH GRPDUSHL[HRXPLOK}HVGHRXWUDVHVSpFLHVQDWXUDLVDVTXDLVXPWXEDUmR SDUWLFXODUSHUWHQFH"(PYLUWXGHGRTXHTXDOTXHUSHQVDPHQWRGD6ROLWiULD-{ FRQWHULDRFRQFHLWRWXEDUmRFRPRRSRVWRDRVFRQFHLWRVWXEDUmRFDEHoDGH PDUWHORRXTXDOTXHUGRVDOWHUQDWLYRV"%$.(5DS

2 SRQWRFKDYH QD DUJXPHQWDomR GH /\QQH %DNHU p R SDSHO TXH D ÓLQJXDJHPS~EOLFDµWHPQRHVWDEHOHFLPHQWRGRVFRQFHLWRV6HPHVVDOLQJXDJHP RXUHGX]LGDjSRVVLELOLGDGHGHXPDGHÀQLomRRVWHQVLYDQmRVHWHULDPRVÚHFXUVRV GHVFULWLYRVµ QHFHVViULRV SDUD À[DU D H[WHQVmR GR FRQFHLWR GH XPD HVSpFLH GH WXEDUmRHGLIHUHQFLiORGDVRXWUDVHVSpFLHVSRUH[HPSOR(SRUQmRWHUWDPEpP RFRQFHLWRDEVWUDWRGH´HVSpFLHQDWXUDOµD6ROLWiULD-{QmRWHULDFRPRUHIHULUVH DXPDHVSpFLHGHWXEDUmRRTXHVHULDSRVVtYHOVH´>@KRXYHVVHDPHGLDomRGDV SUiWLFDVVRFLDLVHOLQJtVWLFDV>@µ%$.(5DS/\QQH%DNHUFRQFOXL UHVVDOWDQGRDLPSRUWkQFLDGDOLQJXDJHPSDUDRFRQWH~GRGRSHQVDPHQWRRXÝLGD LQWHULRUµGHXPDSHVVRD

(21)

SULPHLUDYLVWDDVFRQVLGHUDo}HVDQWHULRUHVVXJHUHPTXHDRHQIDWL]DU D LPSRUWkQFLD GD FRPXQLGDGH OLQJXtVWLFD SDUD D SRVVH GH FRQFHLWRV /\QQH %DNHU HVWDULD SRVWXODQGR TXH D ´VROLWiULD -{µ WHULD YLGD LQWHULRU H[WUHPDPHQWH HPSREUHFLGD SHOR IDWR GH HOD QmR SHQVDU LVWR p GH QmR WHU FUHQoDV GHVHMRV RX LQWHQo}HV DV TXDLV QmR H[LVWLULDP VHP FRQWH~GR VHP FRQFHLWRV ´>@ WHU RV FRQFHLWRV p LPSRUWDQWH SRUTXH D FODVVH GH SHQVDPHQWRV TXH DOJXpP SRGH HQWUHWHUpOLPLWDGDSHORVFRQFHLWRVTXHHOHWHPµ%$.(5DS1HVVH VHQWLGR D ÀOyVRID HVWDULD UHGX]LQGR D YLGD LQWHULRU GD ´VROLWiULD -{µ TXDQGR PXLWRDH[SHULrQFLDVTXDOLWDWLYDVQmRPXLWRGLIHUHQWHVGDTXHODVTXHSRGHULDPVHU DWULEXtGDVDDOJXQVWLSRVGHDQLPDLV(VVDLQWHUSUHWDomRGRSHQVDPHQWRGH/\QQH %DNHUSDUHFHH[FHVVLYDGLDQWHGDGLVWLQomRTXHHODHVWDEHOHFHHQWUH´FRQGLo}HV GHLQGLYLGXDomRµH´FRQGLo}HVGHDTXLVLomRµGHXPFRQFHLWR$HVVHUHVSHLWRD ÀOyVRIDDUJXPHQWDVHPPDLRUHVHVFODUHFLPHQWRVTXHDVSUiWLFDVOLQJXtVWLFDVVmR FRQGLo}HVHVVHQFLDLVDSHQDVSDUDDDTXLVLomRGHFRQFHLWRVDVSHFWRTXHPDLVD LQWHUHVVDHGRTXDOHODVHRFXSDPDVQmRSDUDDVXDLQGLYLGXDomR

(X DGPLWR TXH RV FRQFHLWRV WXEDUmR H JROÀQKR VmR individuados

LQGHSHQGHQWHPHQWHGHSUiWLFDVOLQJXtVWLFDVHVRFLDLV0DVR([WHUQDOLVPR6RFLDO FRPRHXRWHQKRIRUPXODGRQmRHVWiSUHRFXSDGRFRPFRPRRVFRQFHLWRVVmR LQGLYLGXDGRVPDVDQWHVFRPDVFRQGLo}HVVREDVTXDLVXPDSHVVRDWHPXPFHUWR FRQFHLWRHRVSHQVDPHQWRVFRQWHQGRR2IDWRGHTXHXPFRQFHLWRpLQGLYLGXDGR LQGHSHQGHQWHPHQWHGHSUiWLFDVOLQJXtVWLFDVHVRFLDLVpLUUHOHYDQWHSDUDRIDWRGH HOH VHU RX QmR XP FRQFHLWR ([WHUQDOLVWD 6RFLDO 8P FRQFHLWR p XP FRQFHLWR ([WHUQDOLVWD6yFLDVHDOJXpPRWHPGHSHQGHGHSUiWLFDVVRFLDLVHOLQJXtVWLFDVD GHVSHLWRGHFRPRRFRQFHLWRpLQGLYLGXDGR%$.(5DS

&RPR HQWHQGHU HVVD GLVWLQomR HP HVSHFLDO R TXH HOD FRQFHEH FRPR ´FRQGLo}HVGHLQGLYLGXDomRµGHXPFRQFHLWR"(PRXWURWH[WRHVVDGLVWLQomRWDPEpP DSDUHFHHPERUDHPWHUPRVXPSRXFRGLIHUHQWHVPDVQmRPDLVHVFODUHFHGRUD

([WHUQDOLVPRpXVXDOPHQWHHQWHQGLGRFRPRXPDWHVHVREUHFRPRFRQWH~GRV GH SHQVDPHQWR VmR LQGLYLGXDGRV ([LVWHP GXDV PDQHLUDV GH HQWHQGHU HVVD WHVH²RXDQWHVGRLVPRGRVSHORVTXDLVDVFDUDFWHUtVWLFDVGRDPELHQWHSRGHP FRQWULEXLU SDUD R FRQWH~GR GR SHQVDPHQWR GH XPD SHVVRD $ SULPHLUD LQWHUSUHWDomR IRFD QRpensamento TXDLV VmR DV FRQGLo}HV VRE DV TXDLV XP

SHQVDPHQWRWHPRFRQWH~GRSDUWLFXODUTXHHOHWHP"$VHJXQGDLQWHUSUHWDomR

foca no pensador 4XDLV VmR DV FRQGLo}HV VRE DV TXDLV XPD SHVVRDtem um

SHQVDPHQWRFRPXPFRQWH~GRSDUWLFXODU"%$.(5ES

(22)

SHOR PRGR FRPR HVVD FRPXQLGDGH R XWLOL]D -i D TXHVWmR GD LQGLYLGXDomR GD TXDODÀOyVRIDQmRVHRFXSDSDUHFHPHLPSRUWDQWHMXVWDPHQWHSRUDSRQWDUSDUD FRQGLo}HVSULPHLUDVVHPDVTXDLVRSHQVDPHQWRWDPEpPQmRVHULDSRVVtYHOTXHU GL]HUFRQGLo}HVQHFHVViULDVDLQGDTXHQmRVXÀFLHQWHVSDUDRVXUJLPHQWRGHXP FRQFHLWRQRkPELWRGHXPDFRPXQLGDGHOLQJXtVWLFD7UDWRGHFRQGLo}HVSULPHLUDV FRQVLGHUDQGRTXHWRGRFRQFHLWRWHPXPDKLVWyULDRXVHMDDSDUHFHXSULPHLUDPHQWH HP DOJXP PRPHQWR QR kPELWR GD FRPXQLGDGH 1mR PH SDUHFH TXH WHQKDP TXHWHUVXUJLGRFROHWLYDPHQWH(RTXHDPHXYHUpRPDLVLPSRUWDQWHQmRPH SDUHFH UD]RiYHO VXSRU TXH RV FRQFHLWRV SRU PDLV DEVWUDWRV TXH VHMDP SRVVDP VHUDGTXLULGRVVHPH[SHULrQFLDVTXDOLWDWLYDVLQGLYLGXDLVSRUH[HPSORSHUFHSo}HV H[WHUQDVRXLQWHUQDVWLGDVFRPRQmRFRQFHLWXDLVRXFRPRQmRSHQVDPHQWRSHOR ([WHUQDOLVPR6RFLDO/HPEUDQGRWRGDDWUDGLomRHPSLULVWDQD)LORVRÀDFRPRVHULD SRVVtYHOKDYHUFRQFHLWRVGHGRUGHFRUVHPH[SHULrQFLDVVXEMHWLYDVTXHDQFRUHP HVVHVFRQFHLWRVDLQGDTXHHOHVQmRVHUHGX]DPRXQmRVHFRQIXQGDPFRPHODV" $TXHVWmRpVHVHULDSRVVtYHOWHUDVFRQGLo}HVGHDSOLFDomRTXHWRUQDPSRVVtYHO D DTXLVLomR LQGLYLGXDO GRV FRQFHLWRV ´JUDPDµ H ´YHUGHµ WDO FRPR DSDUHFHP QD FLWDomRTXHVHJXHVHPTXHRLQGLYtGXRWHQKDDVH[SHULrQFLDVTXDOLWDWLYDVLQGLYLGXDLV 3RGHULDPHVVDVH[SHULrQFLDVVHULQFOXtGDVGHQWUHDV´FRQGLo}HVGHLQGLYLGXDomRµGH XPFRQFHLWRQHFHVViULDVSDUDDVXDDTXLVLomRVHQGRHVVDSRUVXDYH]WHVWLÀFDGD SRUVXDDSURSULDGDDSOLFDomRWDOFRPRGHVFULWDDEDL[R

(X GLUHL TXH DOJXpP ´WHPµ XP FRQFHLWR VH DOJXpP p FDSD] GH HQWUHWHU SHQVDPHQWRV TXH WrP R FRQFHLWR FRPR XP FRQVWLWXLQWH 6H DOJXpP p FDSD] GH HQWUHWHU R SHQVDPHQWR $ JUDPD p YHUGH HVVH DOJXpP WHP RV FRQFHLWRV JUDPDHYHUGH5HFRQKHFLGDPHQWHJUDPDHYHUGHVmRDPERVFRQFHLWRV YDJRV SHOR IDWR GH DV FRQGLo}HV GH DSOLFDomR GH FDGD XP GHOHV GHL[DU FDVRV IURQWHLULoRV1RHQWDQWRH[LVWHPDOJXPDVFRQGLo}HVVREDVTXDLVFDGDXPDSOLFD VHGHÀQLWLYDPHQWHHDOJXPDVFRQGLo}HVVREDVTXDLVFDGDXPGHÀQLWLYDPHQWH QmRVHDSOLFD3DUDVHWHUXPFRQFHLWRQRVHQWLGRUHOHYDQWHVHGHYHVHUFDSD]GH DSOLFiORFRUUHWDPHQWHHPXPDYDULHGDGHGHFRQWH[WRV%$.(5S

(23)

4 CONCLUSÃO

$RÀQDOL]DUJRVWDULDGHGHVWDFDUDTXHOHVTXHSHQVRVHUHPRVSULQFLSDLV OLPLWHVGR([WHUQDOLVPR6RFLDOHPUHODomRjVTXHVW}HVGDPHQWH$RSULYLOHJLDUD RULJHPH[WHUQDGRVFRQWH~GRVGHSHQVDPHQWRRXVHMDGRVFRQFHLWRVHDRGHÀQLU R SHQVDPHQWR HP WHUPRV GH DWLWXGHV SURSRVLFLRQDLV GHL[DVH GH ODGR DLQGD TXHQmRVHQHJXHDH[LVWrQFLDFRPRSURFXUHLPRVWUDURDVSHFWRTXDOLWDWLYRRX IHQRPrQLFRGDVH[SHULrQFLDVVXEMHWLYDVLQWUtQVHFRDRVVHQWLPHQWRVHVHQVDo}HV H[WHUQDV H LQWHUQDV 0DV QmR VHULDP RV VHQWLPHQWRV H VHQVDo}HV FRQVLGHUDGRV HP VHX FDUiWHU IHQRPrQLFR WDPEpP IRUPDV GH SHQVDPHQWR FRPR GHIHQGLD 'HVFDUWHV H QHVVH VHQWLGR LQVHSDUiYHLV GD LQWHQFLRQDOLGDGH" 1mR WHULD R SHQVDPHQWRFRQFHLWXDOWDPEpPXPFDUiWHUIHQRPHQDO"-XOJRDUHVSRVWDDHVVDV TXHVW}HVLPSRUWDQWHSRLVHQWHQGRFRPRMiRIULVHLQDLQWURGXomRGHVWHDUWLJR TXHHODVQRVUHPHWHPLQHYLWDYHOPHQWHDRVSUREOHPDVGDQDWXUH]DGDPHQWHHGH VXDUHODomRFRPRFRUSRFRPRUHYHODRH[HPSORSDUDGLJPiWLFRGH'HVFDUWHV

/\QQH %DNHU FULWLFD 'HVFDUWHV SHOR IDWR GH R ÀOyVRIR HP VXD YLVmR VROLSVLVWD QmR OHYDU HP FRQVLGHUDomR D H[LVWrQFLD GH FRPXQLGDGHV VRFLDLV H OLQJtVWLFDV VHP DV TXDLV QmR VHULD SRVVtYHO VHU XP LQGLYtGXR DXWRFRQVFLHQWH SHVVRDQRVWHUPRVGDÀOyVRIDRXVHMD´>@LQGLYtGXRVFDSD]HVGHUHÁHWLUVREUH VLPHVPRVFRPRVLPHVPRVµ%$.(5S(VWDQGRVR]LQKRQRPXQGR FRQWLQXD/\QQH%DNHU'HVFDUWHVQmRVHULDFDSD]GHWHUSHQVDPHQWRVDFHUFDGHVL PHVPRWDLVFRPRSHUJXQWDUVHHOHHVWDULDRXQmRVRQKDQGRRXVHQGRHQJDQDGR SRUXP*rQLR0DOLJQRSRLVQmRVHULDFDSD]GHWHUFRQFHLWRVFRQVWLWXWLYRVGHVHX SHQVDPHQWRWDLVFRPR´(Xµ´IRJRµH´UREHµ3DUD/\QQH%DNHU´>@DGHFLVmR GH'HVFDUWHVGHROKDUDVLPHVPRFRPRQmRWHQGR¶PmRVROKRVFDUQHVDQJXH VHQWLGRV·QmRpXPSHQVDPHQWRTXH'HVFDUWHVSRGHULDWHUWLGRVHHOHWLYHVVHVLGR YHUGDGHLURRIDWRGHHOHWHUWLGRDTXHOHSHQVDPHQWRJDUDQWLXTXHHOHHUDIDOVR 6ROLSVLVPRpXPDIDQWDVLDGRVÀOyVRIRVµ%$.(5S3RGHVHFRQVWDWDU TXHRIRFRSULQFLSDOGHVVDFUtWLFDD'HVFDUWHVUHVLGHQRPRGRGHDTXLVLomRGRV FRQWH~GRVGHSHQVDPHQWR8P´VROLWiULR'HVFDUWHVµQmRSRGHULDWHUSHQVDPHQWRV FRPRVFRQWH~GRVTXHHOHWHPLVWRpFRQFHLWRVRVTXDLVGHSHQGHULDPGHIDWRUHV H[WHUQRVDHOHRPXQGRH[WHUQRPDWHULDOHHPHVSHFLDOXPDSDUWHLPSRUWDQWH

desse mundo, a comunidade linguística.

(24)

PRGRVFRQVWLWXDDHVVrQFLDGRHVStULWRRXVXEVWkQFLDSHQVDQWHDPDLRUSDUWH GHVHXFRQWH~GRRXVHMDXPJUDQGHQ~PHURGHVXDLGHLDVSURYpPGDUHODomR FRP R FRUSR H DWUDYpV GR FRUSR GR PXQGR H[WHUQR 5HFRUGHPRV TXH SDUD

Descartes QyV WHPRV WUrV WLSRV GH LGHLDV DV LGHLDV LQDWDV TXHU GL]HU DTXHODV

TXHQRVVmRFRORFDGDVDRQDVFHUWDLVFRPRDSUySULDLGHLDGH'HXVHDVLGHLDV PDWHPiWLFDV DV LGHLDV DGYHQWtFLDV RX VHMD DTXHODV TXH DGYrP GD H[SHULrQFLD FRPRDLGHLDGHFDYDORHDLGHLDGHDVDHSRUÀPDVLGHLDVÀFWtFLDVLVWRpDTXHODV TXHVmRFRQVWUXtGDVSHORHVStULWRFRPRUHVXOWDGRGHVHXSHQVDPHQWRLPDJLQDWLYR DSDUWLUGDVLGHLDVSURYHQLHQWHVGDH[SHULrQFLDSRUH[HPSORDLGHLDGHFDYDOR DODGR&DEHREVHUYDUTXHWDQWRSDUD'HVFDUWHVTXDQWRSDUDRVUDFLRQDOLVWDVHP JHUDODWpPHVPRDVLGHLDVLQDWDVSUHFLVDPGDH[SHULrQFLDGRHVStULWRQRPXQGR SDUDVHWRUQDUHPFRQVFLHQWHV3DUHFHPHHQWmRGHDFRUGRFRPRTXHDÀUPHL TXH'HVFDUWHVFRUURERUDULDDWHVHH[WHUQDOLVWDVHJXQGRDTXDODVFDUDFWHUtVWLFDV GR DPELHQWH GR SHQVDGRU GHWHUPLQDULDP ´IUHTXHQWHPHQWHµ H ´HP SDUWHµ RV FRQWH~GRVGRSHQVDPHQWR0DVLVVRQmRVLJQLÀFDTXHSDUD'HVFDUWHVDDWLYLGDGH SHQVDQWH RX VHMD RV DFRQWHFLPHQWRV PHQWDLV VHMDP HQTXDQWR WDLV H[WHUQRV DR VXMHLWR SHQVDQWH 3HQVR VHU FODUR TXH SDUD 'HVFDUWHV RV FRQWH~GRV GRV SHQVDPHQWRV GD PHQWH GHYHP HP JHUDO VHU FRPSUHHQGLGRV UHODFLRQDOPHQWH LVWRpOHYDQGRVHHPFRQWDRFRUSRHRDPELHQWHH[WHUQRQDWXUDOHFXOWXUDOR TXHQmRVLJQLÀFDTXHRSHQVDPHQWRVHMDHPVLPHVPRXPDDWLYLGDGHH[WHUQDDR VXMHLWRSHQVDQWH&RPRVDEHPRVSDUD'HVFDUWHVRSHQVDPHQWRpXPDDWLYLGDGH VXEMHWLYDFRQVFLHQWHDLQGDTXHVHXVFRQWH~GRVDGYHQKDPHPJUDQGHSDUWHGDV FRQWLQJrQFLDVGDUHODomRHQWUHDOPDFRUSRHPXQGR

6HFRQIRUPHSURFXUHLPRVWUDUDLQGDTXHR([WHUQDOLVPR6RFLDOHQIDWL]H RIDWRGHTXHRVFRQWH~GRVGHSHQVDPHQWRRVFRQFHLWRVGHSHQGHPGDUHODomR FRPIDWRUHVH[WHUQRVHPHVSHFLDOGDFRPXQLGDGHOLQJXtVWLFDLVVRQmRVLJQLÀFDD UHGXomRGDPHQWHQHPDRFRUSRQHPDIDWRUHVH[WHUQRVDHODHPXLWRPHQRVD VXDHOLPLQDomR&RPRIULVHLHPRXWUDRSRUWXQLGDGHUHIHULQGRPHjQHFHVVLGDGH GH VHSDUDU D TXHVWmR GD H[SOLFDomR GD RULJHP GR FRQWH~GR GR SHQVDPHQWR H GH VHX SDSHO FDXVDO QLQJXpP GXYLGD GH TXH R SHQVDPHQWR HP YLUWXGH GH VHX FRQWH~GR DIHWD R TXH ID]HPRV 7RGDYLD LVVR SRU VL Vy QmR FRQVWLWXL XPD VROXomRSDUDRSUREOHPDGDUHODomRPHQWHHFRUSRRTXDOGHULYDLQHYLWDYHOPHQWH GD GLVWLQomR PHQWH FRUSR H PXQGR SUREOHPD TXH DSHQDV VH FRORFD GHVGH R PRPHQWRHPTXHVHUHÁHWHDUHVSHLWRGDQDWXUH]DGRSHQVDPHQWRHVHRFRQVLGHUD FRPRGLVWLQWRGRItVLFRHDHOHLUUHGXWtYHO6HQGRRFDVRHPHSDUHFHVHUHVVDD

_{(VWRXDTXLFRQVLGHUDQGRRSHQVDPHQWRGH'HVFDUWHVUHVXOWDQWHGDVVHLVPHGLWDo}HVPHWDItVLFDV}

(25)

SRVLomRGR([WHUQDOLVPR6RFLDOHVVDDERUGDJHPQmRGHYHULDVHUWRPDGDFRPR XPDDOWHUQDWLYDHÀFD]SDUDRHQIUHQWDPHQWRGHVVHVSUREOHPDVÀORVyÀFRV

&2(/+2 -RQDV *RQoDOYHV 6RFLDO H[WHUQDOLVP PLQG WKRXJKW DQG ODQJXDJHTrans/ Form/Ação0DUtOLDYQS-DQ$EULO

ABSTACT 0\ DLP LV WR VKRZ WKDW WKH H[WHUQDOLVW WKHVHV ´PHDQLQJV DUH QRW LQ WKH KHDGµ DQG

´WKRXJKWVDUHQRWLQWKHKHDGµGRQRWQHFHVVDULO\LPSO\WKHPRUHH[WUHPHWKHVLVWKDW´WKHPLQGLVQRW LQWKHKHDGµ,FRQVLGHUWKLVTXHVWLRQLQWHUPVRI WKHVRFLDOH[WHUQDOLVPDSSURDFKRI 7\OHU%XUJHDQG /\QQH%DNHUDUJXLQJWKDWWKHLPSRUWDQFHWKHVHWKLQNHUVDWWULEXWHWRODQJXDJHLQTXHVWLRQVUHODWLYHWR the mind does not mean either the reduction of the mind to language or the elimination of the mind. 0\FRQFOXVLRQLVWKDWVRFLDOH[WHUQDOLVPLVQRWDQHIÀFLHQWVWUDWHJ\IRUGHDOLQJZLWKSUREOHPVRI WKH QDWXUHRI WKHPLQGRUWKHUHODWLRQVKLSEHWZHHQPLQGDQGERG\

KEYWORDSVRFLDOH[WHUQDOLVP/\QQH%DNHU7\OHU%XUJHPLQGWKRXJKWODQJXDJH

REFERÊNCIAS

%$.(5/\QQH5)LUVW3HUVRQ([WHUQDOLVP. The Modern Schoolman/;;;,9

-DQXDU\ 0DUFKD

BBBBBB6RFLDO([WHUQDOLVPDQG)LUVW3HUVRQ$XWKRULW\. ErkennE

BBBBBB +RZ WR KDYH 6HOI'LUHFWHG $WWLWXGHV ,Q 6&+0,' +DQV %HUQKDUG =,9 $QLWD .RQ]HOPDQQ */225 -XOLHWWH (GSelf-Evaluation: Individual and Collective.

6SULQJHU3XEOLVKLQJ)RUWKFRPLQJ

%85*(7\OHU,QGLYLGXDOLVPDQGWKH0HQWDO. 6WXGLHVLQ0HWDSK\VLFVMidwest Studies in Philosophy,9S

BBBBBBOther Bodies. Thought and Object(VVD\VRQ,QWHQWLRQDOLW\2[IRUG&ODUHQGRQS

BBBBBB,QGLYLGXDOLVPDQG3V\FKRORJ\. The Philosophical Review;&9Q-DQXDU\

BBBBBB,QGLYLGXDOLVPDQG6HOI.QRZOHGJHJournal of Philosophy

(26)

BBBBBBOrigins of objectivity. 1HZ<RUN2[IRUG8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV

&2(/+2 -RQDV $ &DXVDomR 0HQWDO 6HJXQGR R 5HDOLVPR 3UiWLFR GH /\QQH 5XGGHU %DNHUCognitio-Estudos:5HYLVWD(OHWU{QLFDGH)LORVRÀD91GH]HPEUR

3871$0+LOODU\0HDQLQJDQG5HIHUHQFH. The Journal of Philosophy9ROQ

BBBBBBThe meaning of “Meaning”./DQJXDJH0LQGDQG.QRZOHGJH0LQQHVRWD0LQQHVRWD

8QLYHUVLW\3UHVVS