Monte Carlo Modeling of Dual and Triple Photon Energy Absorptiometry Technique

(1)

*

:

!

"

# $

1 * 2

3

1

-! "# $

2

& ' ! "#

$

3

-! "# $

! " #" $ %&'

( )*+ : 24 / 10 / 87 $ "23#" 4

: 11 / 3 / 87

( 56

/0

:

! "#$ %! & ' ( ) *

+,- - ! . )/-! 0 1& + 2 &3 4 - 5( 61 78 9 :;

4 -<+- '

.

)+- > 4 & 4 * ? 61 !5 &@ * A B 5 &3> 3

4& C

.

+3 ) 3 -* & ;4 4 2

MCNP

%! & + ! > D - $ -*

%! & EF

C 8G@4! + * ) B & 2 H ! * I D*

' *

+ ( * C

-> D

.

1 2

:

& ;4*

%! *

+3 9 ) *

MCNP

+4

.

& ;4 -*

%! J ) 3

-* -5< K ! L +M . D * -5 +4

.

& ;4N 2 < O ! &,) 7-* P 2 - @ *

@ ! 0 Q

R

+4 - 9 ! R S K2 H ! - ₅_*

.

+3

MCNP

A -+ +3J

-3& ! @) ! ! 0 F GT - * 5 -&3 ) 3

.

3"

:

" & $ - * C + 61

+ - R 3 ( * & ) -! %!

.

* & ) -& %!

-+ ) ;VG V( *W & %! &3 ) K ₄ _- ₍ ₆₁_*W _! .

456

:

. ) -2 C A * & ) -& %! ( 61 ; XM

+4 - &

.

+- 3 G ) !

+4 -YX '-*W & Y ,Z : [ & ! 4 M & *W & %!

.

! 7

:

\ +MG@I-& +-5]T * *+-5 3GK + & "#$%!

+4

. ) ! @4PDJ P &X9-4

4 16 ! 17 ! P D -86 : 73 -65 (

/ ( 78

:

! "#$%! & "#$%!

61

' 9 )

& ;4 -* +3 ) 3

(2)

1 -4

!" #$%

& & '

.

) # * +

" ,

-& . /" * 0 # 1 .+ 2

#3 #4 / 5 67 8 / / /&

/" -& , " !"

.

9 17

: 7 7 -& ;< = 6>

!" , # 1 ?2 % #

"

.

* , @ ' A & 6 5 B67

" 9 17 C

.

D

' A & 6 - 7 # E E !& '

?2 ' #E & # / 2 D F 8

G %

. ' #& 2 H!& " I J8

0 4 - 7 ! B B67 @

K #' * , '

.

-& ' #E & D

, /7 2 ' A & 6 # E *, #

:

M# N7 O #7 P ' #E 7 QJ8. M#

H!& 7# M# QJ8 7 '

.

R/ # 1 0 4 # E *,

! 9 17

.

-& # #&

# E5!" # , /7 2 # E*, S

!" 2C # E *, . 0 @ " T+% .

7 /BP & U #@ A # V7 #

]

1

[

.

O # *, : / 7 2 O6> X<

#&J #!7 B < ? 7#7 ! B #& Y

Y # E *, K & 7 # E *,

/ 1 O <

.

0 4 /

Y *, 4 7 -& # O6> .

0 4 < Y * // H! / * Z& #" # E *, #!7 -& # X<

/ N& K *, 4 7* . [

.

- 7 R/ & #

!"

\,I S #" + 2 #'

< # # E *, O6> . # E A > 68

.

# R/ 9 " # # ] /4

* @ A & 6 A # V7 & A #[ E *, X< . # E A > 9 1 , #7 KC #

O6>

.

A & 6 # E *, * X<

, # C ^I 7 ' QJ8 D

2 %

# F

7 #4 ;&, 7 % /!& \ , " $% . O6> ,

10 %

* "* D E

]

2

[

.

, $%-&

D " "

0 7 ' QJ8 \ #

5 " # E #R # b0c

;&, 7 J0 F " \# '

" # E*, O6> $% & ?2 #4 .

-& " # E *, O6># #4 ' & ' #[

J8D 0 4

" # 7 ' Q

# E *, 6> 2C # D /4 # HP

D C K&, # 7 ' QJ8 D

, * b 0

MCNP-4C

, 2"

K / &,

.

E % / 0 #[ - /]

0 4 # E *, O6> # D

" # 7 ' QJ8

.

2 -8 )8 9

& !

D ,

, C8 * " '#E &

0 4

7 ' QJ8 D

.

D -&

7 ' 2 ' , & M# &

(3)

A > d#' # E

.

^I

# 67 :

,

* " 5 !17 \# ' b0c

^ [

# / 2 & Z , % , 7 ' 2 /& #'

# e f7 ?& #g -& 7# 2 AI /

#&,A > # % d#' & : ) 1 ( )] ( exp[

0h msh s mbh b

h I x x

I = µ +µ

)] (

exp[

0l msl s mbl b

l I x x

I = µ +µ

# l I . h I . l I₀ . h I₀ . msl µ . msh µ . mbl µ . mbh µ . s x . b x Z ) 1 ( ' ? 7#7

, /7 2

:

7 ' A "

.* # 2 M# K

A "

7 ' .* # 2 M# #

7 ' 0 A " K

. M# 7 ' 0 A " . M# #

e f7 ?&#g

# ' #8

7 ' M# * 6 \

. M# K

M# * 6 \# ' #8 e f7 ?&#g

7 ' . M# #

#8 e f7 ?&#g 7 ' M# * 6 . M# K

?&#g

7 ' * 6 #8 e f7

M# # . #8 g ) ? : # 2 gcm ( Z 7 7 ' * \# ' . " #8 g

7 'Z 7

*

"

.

0 * -& 5:

-. 0 C

b x & : ) 2 ( mbl mbh s l l h h s b R I I I I R x µ µ = ) ln( )

ln( 0 0

msh msl s R µ µ = ] 1 [ .

7 ' D ,

\# ' mb0c A n

d#' , 7. /

&

#4o/ ;

?2 \# ' &

E *, 6> $% #

"

.

,

&

D , * b #/

& #4 p # mb0

#R E > 7 # " . & ! , & D -;8# ] 2 [ > 7 7D * " K

& ' & b0c

7 ' QJ8 "

.

q &

D / D

-7 ' #4mb0 , "

'#E#R & K & & m0 N & B2< m0 #

" ' g

.

&

-90 % \# ' , /7 2 * " '#E #R mb0 D

)

#4

(

.Q#4 ' .

.

&

-@ g5 D

7 'Z 7* "

/ '

#R \ m0

E #

.

& 7#7 -A > AI ?

,& # &/ : ) 3 ( )] ( exp[

0h lsh s lbh b lfh f

h I t t t

I = µ +µ +µ

)] (

exp[

0l lsl s lbl b lfl f

l I t t t

I = µ +µ +µ

f b

s t t

t

T = + +

# ' ! Z ) 3 ( D 1 c b0 " &

#g A b7

-& f7 ? g e . $% /" m$ i i i t x =

0 @ g

-#<# #8 g

.

^ / g & H f p # #4 ^+3 /" f t

#4 g #

"

.

, A n g.s '* 5:

& # & . ) 4 ( 1 1 1 1 1 1 ) / ln( ) / ln( 0 0 lfl lbl lsl lfh lbh lsh lfl l l lsl lfh h h lsh b I I I I t µ µ µ µ µ µ µ µ µ µ = & D N & # # #4#[ - '#E#R

#

7 ' , * b '#E #< 8 7 M#

A b F "

&

7# 2 AI A n/

, A n & # & . )] (

exp[ ₁ ₁ ₁

01

1 I ls ts lbtb lf tf

I = µ +µ +µ

) 5 (

)] (

exp[ ₂ ₂ ₂

02

2 I ls ts lb tb lf tf

I = µ +µ +µ

)] (

exp[ ₃ ₃ ₃

03

3 I ls ts lb tb lf tf

(4)

& H

1

.

2 3

M# v / 1 / E

&

# #

# 7^+2< & * "e

.

s '* 5:

w A n g

& 5 &

.

) 6 (

3 3 3

2 2 2

1 1 1

3 03

3 3

2 02

2 2

1 01

1 1

) / ln(

lf lb ls

lf ls

b

I I

t

µ µ µ

µ µ

=

2 -1

-# D N& 0 , 2"

# 5& 5:

" T : ' n7 m&

.

2" S -&

T Y # 0 $ # -&# C , !& ,

# # y b:- /] C C1/! # A w

" / , 7

.

MCNP

* R/ /4 N&

5z # # 7 0

A P #7

/ 7 w

# !0 7 ' . #7

#

.

7 # # y b: 5 " G % #

N& ' . ' #E & . 7 # # , { b: . # &, " #6 . !" ., !" 5 B67 : #@.

.* / Q " # U : #@ ' !" : #@

" 2

.

/ . M# 7 -& A ! ,

# * " , , 5Y ' & K 7

.

M#

* 6 C #7

10

7

20

0 # !0 B M#

C # !0 C 7 '

* 6

1

0 # !0 B 7

1000

0 # !0 &, , 2"5 <

"

]

3

[

.

* / 5 !17 * 0 / N&, -&

#< 8 N& 8 | $ n6 & C0 B

/ * b '#E

.

& # Z 7 5& '

" Z 7 & C

MCNP

5& '-& F " * % e > 7. / A n 1 5 2<, 7 +@ * # E#

A w 14A n 1 ! . C ;@ Y =$ Q * 6

8 #%S . /" # !0 & 7 '. #7 7

2C # H & D S #

A > ,

" . # E

.

" * b $Y ;$Y =$ , ^ 20 }

q# 5 < #E ;$Y =$ A +@ 4#E

/"

.

E / # . -& C 7 ' #

# } q

q B' 7T : . z

.N&# !0 7 'QJ8, /

7 * # ~ , 0 7

#7 7- /] B6

/& Q :

] 3 .[

2 -2

-D ,

B2< * "* #2 / 2

f7 # 7# e . "

& #g, & f7 ? e

, 7# " " S+@ JE

K

.

-& 5 #

nY

#& Y -& 0 , 2" , * b

K&

.

N& / !&

A " 7# 0

I

* ,

g t

m$ . / JE

) exp(

0 t

I

I = µ

A "

-7# 0 7# #<# * , * # JE

.

µ ?&#g

* $% e f7

7# M# * H/8 "

.

Y # B * N&

µ -&

N7 14 N&, K ? 7#7 1& ,

K / * b #R M# M#

&, # * + 7

K

7 ' A " .•6 * g # V7

.* , * # JE I

K& . .

N& D, # /6/

/6/ , & I

? :# t

Y . µ &

.

#

, #

7# 0 % Y # E / #

I \,I

, !" 7 0 #<# * +

-7# ZY' &

7 / 0 7# M#

I K / 2[

(5)

' QJ8D , 2" K& n< ,

7

M# , K&, #P 7 '

44

.

5 / 59 100

0 # !0 B #y /

, * " 5 E C&M#

Gd

153

) 44 100

0 # !0 B

(

Am

254

) 5 / 59

# !0 B

0

(

* b ' FK / JE 7# , &

.90 % \# ' , /7 2 / ' p B . #4 '

\#

–

#& Y & J0. #4

µ

M# -& #

K& * "# w

.

5!" T , #& Y -& #

) 1 (

* b

K /

.

N& & R/ 14 B8 # 7 0

7# 7 ' , N& '#E #< M# N7

7 ' UJ: R/ , !" # 7 0

'#E #< E / #

.

# U * g

* " * # \ , !& , 2" , . "

1

# B 7

10

# B # V7 /

.

5 !17 #> / ? #7

* / \# ' p B . #4 ' .90 % \# '

–

* # ! , 2"-& #4

;8# , * "

] 4 [

* "~ #

.

1

-, eB g * 7 , 2"

1 / 0

7

1

#R * , #

#< 2 K

7 '

#R M# M# N7

) 44

.

5 / 59 100

0 # !0 B

(

7 ' 7 . C , * " *

K /! ' & # 8 #% , !" .

\ < -&

& $ , &

) exp(

0 t

I

I = µ

// #

I 7 ' 7 , !" * " *

"

t

#R * g

.

D, # /6/ , &

Y .\ < -& µ

&

.

& Y #& Y µ

, * "~ # /6/

* " ~ # < #& Y .

;8# ,

] 5 [

R:+ < #& Y - $% "

- * " , 2" #& Y

47 / 0 %

7

1 % .

, /& 6>

= )& , 2"

$ -ƒ

" & K

.

* b e f7 ?& #g /

, 2" D , 2" K& *

7 'QJ8 K&, #

.

2 -3

! "#$% &

' ( &

p B 5 " 14 N& , D -& , 2" #

Gd

153

) 44 100

0 # !0 B

(

Am

254

) 5 / 59

0 # !0 B

(

* b K /

C&M# 7 #'

!& 2 * " '#E#R

.

D -& ^

, , 2"-& K& ~ : 7 ' M#

* b M#

)& - & Y N& K K /

K \ * 0 M# Q , 5> :

M# K& D -& # / C

.

*, ^ 20 } q & : , 2"-& # E 0 4 #< & ,

#R # E

K&# E

.

5!" T : -&

) 2 (

"

.

? 7#7 \# ' T g

55 / 0 6

#

' @

' 90 %\#

C g 2 / & ' &G n % #4

50:50

.

] 2 [

# [„7 #

, 7 # &

(6)

V7 \# ' 5 g - " * [

#4 KC #

,

10 %

7

90 %

2" \ ,

, # & K

.

& )

5!" , 5> : )

4 (

& * "

.

2

-! "# $

2 -4

-* +

' ( $

&

* b gK& n< ,

QJ8 D ,

- " * [ FK& 7 '

, T g .\# ' g

4 / 0

7

7 / 0

#

-/

#y 232

/ 1 156 / 2

# \#E

; # # /"

-# V7 K

.

g 5& 27 #

0 4 C . #8 g !& '

T #

) 08 / 3

; # # # \#E

(

K& * # Q#g

.

,

5!" /

) 1 (

*#C , 2" \ # K&# E

.

& )

# 5!" p )

5 (

* "* 1

. 2

-5

-& -. /+ & 0 1 & +

0 Z $ , # ƒ + 2 3

%

,

, %

& # -& F /

*#b: "# E

† &

: / & F

, - ,

' / 1

.

5: # , # ƒ , , #

!/& -! # y d 0

# ‡0 " 8 %

50

7

70

, >

, % ]

6 .[

# #

/ 0 #[

E % 5!" )& #

D , *

s ' &

-5 E

/ K

.

S

E % # C8 " 0

#R

E % K : $ K&# E 0 : -&

E %5!" ZY' C A b7 /" K # #

"

)

5!"

3 ( .

*#b: K0 9 " # &

#R *#b:-& # # E , H K&# E

E % E

7

60 %

6> # . #

D < 7 ' QJ8

5!" S # [ 7 K&, #

E % # )& #

K /

.

3

-& '( )* +,

'-. / * 0 # 12&3 45

3 -:" ;'

p $%

1

.

2 3

5!"

) 4 (

M# Q ? 7#7

44 -5 / 59

.

44 -100 5 / 59 -100

B # !0 0

*

.

* O8 7

K &

0 : -&# C

)

Z%

2 ( 4 %

Z $%

K "

#E # E -K /!

/ 1

69 / 7 %

(7)

m 0 †# 0 , # ƒ + 2 2

%

6> $% Y -& .

# E *,

1 m 0 A # V7 7

.

* & #4 ' g & ' "

* & #' * )& . "

< Y , # Y N" -! /"

9 17 # * 2 "

y = 1.694

y = -0.0036x + 1.8729 y = -0.003x + 1.8318 y = -0.0021x + 1.7716

1.5 1.55 1.6 1.65 1.7 1.75 1.8 1.85

0 20 40 60 80 100

(g/cm2 )

1

2

3

1 :

3 : 2 :

4

-' 78+9 &0 : ;&

y = 0.0004x + 1.6681

y = -0.003x + 1.8318

y = -0.0129x + 2.103

0.8 1 1.2 1.4 1.6 1.8 2

0 20 40 60 80 100

(g/cm2)

! " #" ! #"

$ % #"

5

-= &3 >

:

DPA

@* A,B

DPA

*C 0 * A,B

M# b0 D , #4#[ #28 #

5!" C )& K / * b

) 5 (

* " * 1

.

$% b0 D , * b " * &

# E *, 6>

7 / 0 %

*

b0c D 0 :

* # # 1 $%

.

# -&

b0 D & " #

K / # \# ' 2@? #7 C8 .

y = x

y = 1.3471x - 0.8307

R2_{= 0.9796}

1 1.2 1.4 1.6 1.8 2 2.2 2.4

(g/cm2) &' "

( ) * )

6

-&" '

'0 E FG.> "#

5!"

) 6 (

7 ' QJ8D " * & :

" %# % 6>, 7 2@Z& #"

.

N4 Y e f7?& #g / #7 #4

" ?& #g-& - $% v / 1

.

5!" #

) 7 ( ) 8 (

, * b K &

m / 7# 2 N& N& 7#

,

Z $

12 %

0 !/& - g K A 2 6 $%

E % 5!" /6/ - U+ % & ?2

) 7 (

* "

.

7# !& 2 # & N& ,

# & )& # & <

C - K

5!" B2< )&

) 8 (

" * 1 *

7 %

Z $%

/"

.

A > # E*, /4 ] /4

$% # E

E % 5!" &

&

(8)

y = -0.0092x + 0.9108 R2_{= 0.9859}

y = -0.0119x + 0.9957 R2

= 0.9572

0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2

0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70

) + ,

( ) *

(g/cm2)

% -!

./"01 -!

7

-'( )* +, /30

&

y = -0.0098x + 0.9166

y = -0.0111x + 0.9684

0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2

0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70

( ) *

(g/cm2)

+ ,

% -!

./"01 -!

8

-'( )* +, /30 ;& / &: &

4

-8 < = ;' > ?

, 2")& O8 7 ' &K 7T "9 1

= 6> *, . 7 ' QJ8

Y , #7

b0c 0 D 2

/ .

, !/& 8 -& # E*, 6> 2C B

' 90 %\# ' Z ? #7 p # mb0c N&

. " * b #4

\# ' #[ b0c D

{ 60 E 8 @ #4 90 %

D "

* b b f7?& #g, # &

C #4#[ "

* "{ 60 .

" * 1 , 2" \ - /] 7

7 ' # / 2 D , * b

5: M#

# E *, . , C 2 p # AI *

?& #g / #7 v, #4 % # 0 4

$% # 3!7?2 A " N4 Y

"

N& 8 # ˆ Y -& - /]

e f7?& #g-& - $% "

.

, !& #7#

-& b0c D

7

&, $%.

#4, " ,

. , #&

N& , D -& -& b0c D

*

7# # # E *, < & ' # / # -&

& , \ , & ' * "

!/& ?2

/

\ # D \,I ,

& # # E *, N&

# EA > 7# # .

Y #'

- K0 #' Y 9 "

& Y

7 #E

+ . " * 9 17

?2

# E*, I O6> , .

b0c D , 7

# * b .

# E*, s 4 #' \ / - /]

, Y

#4 &, # V7 &

A > ?2 . # E

T #4#[ " '#E#R

. b0c

& , 7

# * b D

-.

5

-' 8 5 $

1C C" * 1 1 ‰ 2 1 #g :

(9)

A= B

1. Webber CE. Photon Absorptiometry, bone densitometry and the challenge of osteoporosis. Phys Med Biol

2006; 51:169-185.

2. Michael C J, Henderson C J. Monte Carlo modeling of an extended DXA technique. Phys Med Biol 1998;

43:2583-2596.

3. Briesmeister J F (Ed.). MCNPTM – A General Monte Carlo N-Particle Code, Version 4C, Los Alamos National

Laboratory, Los Alamos, New Mexico; 2000.

4. Snyder WS, Cook MJ, Nasset ES, Karhausen LR, Parry Howells G, Tipton IH. Report of the task group on

reference man. Published for ICRP Pergamon Press; 1975.

5. Berger MJ, Hubbell JH, Seltzer SM. XCOM: Photon Cross Sections Database, NIST Standard Reference

Database 8 (XGAM); 1998.

6. Genant HK. Methods of bone densitometry in current research in osteoporosis and bone mineral measurement,