Atelier Virtual –
Relato de uma
Experiência
.Eduardo Sampaio Nardelli Arquiteto Professor Doutor [email protected]; Charles de Castro Vincent Arquiteto Professor Doutor [email protected];
Universidade Presbiteriana Mackenzie, Brasil.
This work aims to present an
educational experiment in VDS
– Virtual Design Studio at Faculdade
de Arquitetura e Urbanismo
da Universidade Presbiteriana
Mackenzie, São Paulo, Brasil, as
part as the efforts of updating the
Information and Communication
Technologies – ICTs disciplines of
this University. We describe some
previous experiment on which we
based this one and we detail the
structure of our proposal analizing
the results we’ve got.
1. I
ntrodução 2VSULPHLURVUHODWRVGHH[SHULrQFLDVHQYROYHQGR R9LUWXDO'HVLJQ6WXGLRGDWDPGHHVH UHIHUHPDRWUDEDOKRGHVHQYROYLGRSRUGLYHUVDV XQLYHUVLGDGHVGHYiULDVSDUWHVGRPXQGRTXH SDUWLFLSDUDPGHXPWUDEDOKRFRODERUDWLYRGH SURMHWRXVDQGRUHFXUVRVFRPR&$',QWHUQHWH 7HOHFRQIHUrQFLDQXPDWHQWDWLYDGHSHUPLWLU DHVWXGDQWHVGHGLIHUHQWHVFXOWXUDVYLYHQGRD TXLO{PHWURVGHGLVWkQFLDHPGLIHUHQWHVIXVRV KRUiULRVLQWHUDJLUHPWUDEDOKDQGRFROHWLYDPHQWH XPPHVPRWHPDGHSURMHWR:RMWRZLF]D 8PDQRGHSRLVD8QLYHUVLGDGHGH+RQJ.RQJ UHWRPDULDRWHPDSURSRQGRRUHGHVHQKRGRSiWLR GRWUDGLFLRQDOFRQMXQWRUHVLGHQFLDOGH/L/RQJ HP6KDQJDLQXPWUDEDOKRFROHWLYRTXHHQYROYHX DOpPGD8QLYHUVLGDGHGH+RQJ.RQJD(76$%HP %DUFHORQD0,7&RUQHOO:DVKLQJWRQ8QLYHUVLW\ HP6W/RXLVHD8%&HP9DQFRXYHU%UDGIRUG &KHQJH.YDQ $SDUWLUGDtGLYHUVDVH[SHULrQFLDVWrPVLGR UHODWDGDVYDOHQGRFLWDURWUDEDOKRGHVHQYROYLGR DWUDYpVGDSDUFHULDHQWUHD8QLYHUVLGDGHGH+RQJ .RQJR6ZLVV)HGHUDO,QVWLWXWHRI7HFKQRORJ\ HD8QLYHUVLGDGHGH:DVKLQJWRQTXHWLUDQGR SDUWLGRGDGLIHUHQoDGHKRUDVHQWUHRIXVR KRUiULRGHFDGDLQVWLWXLomRGHVHQYROYHX LQLQWHUUXSWDPHQWHHPKRUDVRSURMHWRGH XPDFDVDFRUUHVSRQGHQGRDFDGDHTXLSHXP FLFORGHKRUDVGHWUDEDOKR.RODUHYLFHWDOOL ([SHULrQFLDTXHHYLGHQFLRXRSRWHQFLDO GHUHHVWUXWXUDomRGDGLVWULEXLomRLQWHUQDFLRQDO GRWUDEDOKRDSDUWLUGRXVRLQWHQVLYRGDV 7HFQRORJLDVGD,QIRUPDomRH&RPXQLFDomR7,&V 'RPHVPRPRGRGHVGHR7DOOHU9LUWXDOGHLas Américas vem sendo coordenado pela Texas $ 08QLYHUVLW\FRPDSDUWLFLSDomRGHGLYHUVDV LQVWLWXLo}HVGHWRGRRFRQWLQHQWHDPHULFDQRTXH realizam, no segundo semestre de cada ano, XPDH[SHULrQFLDGLGiWLFDGHGHVHQYROYLPHQWRGR SURMHWRGHXPKRWHODFDGDYH]QXPDORFDOLGDGH GLIHUHQWHGRWHUULWyULRODWLQRDPHULFDQRVRED VXSHUYLVmRGHSURIHVVRUHVGHVVDVLQVWLWXLo}HV 2GHVHQYROYLPHQWRGRVWUDEDOKRVpDFRPSDQKDGR ORFDOPHQWHSRUSHORPHQRVXPSURIHVVRUH DSUHVHQWDGRDWUDYpVGHXPVLWHQD:HED SDUWLUGRTXDORVDOXQRVSDUWLFLSDQWHVUHFHEHP os respectivos comentários de orientadores ORFDOL]DGRVQDVGLIHUHQWHVLQVWLWXLo}HVGRVSDtVHV TXHLQWHJUDPR7DOOHU9LUWXDO 1HVWHFDVRDSRVVLELOLGDGHGHLQWHJUDomR continental e, ao mesmo tempo, a oportunidade GHVHYLYHQFLDUDOJXPDH[SHULrQFLDGHWUDEDOKR FRODERUDWLYRjGLVWkQFLDOHYRXQRVDSURSRU DSDUWLFLSDomRGD)DFXOGDGHGH$UTXLWHWXUDH 8UEDQLVPRGD8QLYHUVLGDGH3UHVELWHULDQD
0DFNHQ]LHQR7DOOHU9LUWXDOGHODV$PpULFDV FRPRSDUWHGRVHVIRUoRVGHDWXDOL]DomRGRV FRQWH~GRVGDVGLVFLSOLQDVGDiUHDGH7HFQRORJLDV GD,QIRUPDomRH&RPXQLFDomRRIHUHFLGDVDRV estudantes desta Universidade. Entretanto, contrariando a expectativa inicial, RDSURYHLWDPHQWRGHQRVVRVHVWXGDQWHVUHYHORX
VHPXLWRDTXpPGRUHVXOWDGRJHUDODSUHVHQWDGR pelo conjunto dos demais participantes, LQGLFDQGRDH[LVWrQFLDGHXPDSRVVtYHOODFXQD HPVXDIRUPDomRDQWHULRUTXHGLÀFXOWDVVH DVXDLQWHJUDomRDRDPELHQWHYLUWXDOGH GHVHQYROYLPHQWRGRVWUDEDOKRVGR7DOOHUGH las Américas. Propusemos, então, a realização de uma
disciplina eletiva, no primeiro semestre ²DQWHULRUSRUWDQWRjUHDOL]DomRGR7DOOHU FRPRREMHWLYRGHFREULUHVVDSRVVtYHOODFXQD introduzindo os eventuais interessados em DOJXPDVWpFQLFDVGHWUDEDOKRFRODERUDWLYR
(VWDH[SHULrQFLDVHGHVHQYROYHXGXUDQWH todo o primeiro semestre deste ano e nos SHUPLWLXREVHUYDUHFRPSUHHQGHUPHOKRU RVDVSHFWRVTXHHQYROYHPDUHDOL]DomRGH WUDEDOKRVFRODERUDWLYRVjGLVWkQFLDVREUHWXGR GHVPLVWLÀFDQGRDVXDHÀFiFLDHSRQWXDQGR GLÀFXOGDGHVDWpPHVPRGHFDUiWHUFXOWXUDOTXH QmRSRGHPVHUVXEHVWLPDGDVSRUDTXHOHVTXHVH interessem pelo tema.
2. A disciplina 2.1. Ementa 3URSRUFLRQDUDRVHVWXGDQWHVGHDUTXLWHWXUDR GHVHQYROYLPHQWRGHXPSURMHWRGHDUTXLWHWXUD XWLOL]DQGRVHSUHIHUHQFLDOPHQWHGHUHFXUVRV GLJLWDLVHH[SHULPHQWDQGRVLWXDo}HVTXH HQYROYDPDWURFDGHLQIRUPDo}HVjGLVWkQFLD GHIRUPDVLQFU{QLFDHRXDVVtQFURQDFRP RREMHWLYRGHDSURIXQGDURVHXGRPtQLRQD XWLOL]DomRGHVVHVUHFXUVRVHFDSDFLWiORVSDUDR GHVHQYROYLPHQWRGHWUDEDOKRVFRODERUDWLYRVj GLVWkQFLDQmRSUHVHQFLDLV 2. 2. Metodologia 2.2.1.$PELHQWHGHWUDEDOKRDGRWDPRVXP DPELHQWHGHWUDEDOKRYLUWXDOXWLOL]DQGR RDSOLFDWLYR0RRGOHTXHVXEVWLWXLX parcialmente a sala de aula, permitindo DUHDOL]DomRGHGLYHUVDVWDUHIDVGHVGH DGHÀQLomRGRFURQRJUDPDDWpD GLVWULEXLomRGHPDWHULDLVUHFHELPHQWR GRVWUDEDOKRVUHDOL]DGRVSHORVDOXQRV FRQWUROHGHLQVFULomRHIUHTrQFLDGRV SDUWLFLSDQWHVDYDOLDo}HVFRPDUHVSHFWLYD DWULEXLomRGHQRWDVHDSRVVLELOLGDGHGH comunicação entre os participantes de IRUPDDVVtQFURQDDWUDYpVGR)yUXPHGH IRUPDVLQFU{QLFDDWUDYpVGH &KDWVH9LGHRFRQIHUrQFLD²QHVWHFDVR SHUPLWLQGRLQFOXVLYHRFRPSDUWLOKDPHQWR VLPXOWkQHRGHRXWURVDSOLFDWLYRVPHVPR TXDQGRLQVWDODGRVHPDSHQDVXPGRV computadores dos participantes.
2.2.2.7DUHIDVDVHUHPUHDOL]DGDVSURMHWRGHXP +RWHO²PHVPRWHPDGR7DOOHU9LUWXDOD ser desenvolvido em grupo, de acordo com RVHJXLQWHURWHLUR 'HÀQLomRGDVHTXLSHVGHWUDEDOKR 5HFRQKHFLPHQWRGDiUHDHHVWXGRGDV VXDVFDUDFWHUtVWLFDVItVLFDVHXUEDQtVWLFDV 3URGXomRGHXPPRGHORHOHWU{QLFR GRORFDO • Estudo de programas de HPSUHHQGLPHQWRVVLPLODUHVMiFRQVWUXtGRV 'HÀQLomRGRSURJUDPDGRKRWHOD VHUSURMHWDGR &RQVWUXomRGRRUJDQRJUDPDHSUp GLPHQVLRQDPHQWRGRVDPELHQWHV (VWXGRGDLPSODQWDomRGHÀQLQGR principais eixos de circulação e PDVVDVHGLÀFDGDV
'HILQLomRGDYROXPHWULDHVLVWHPD HVWUXWXUDO
$SUHVHQWDomRGR3DUWLGR
• Desenvolvimento do Partido ao nível de XP(VWXGR3UHOLPLQDU
$SUHVHQWDomRGR(VWXGR3UHOLPLQDU • Ajustes e desenvolvimento do Estudo 3UHOLPLQDUDRQtYHOGHXP$QWHSURMHWR • Apresentação do Anteprojeto 2.2.3.3URGXWRVDVHUHPHQWUHJXHV
$SUHVHQWDomRHOHWU{QLFDGR3DUWLGRSDUD H[LELomRQD:HE
• Apresentação do Estudo Preliminar através de um site contendo a explicação conceitual do projeto, plantas, 2 cortes, 4 HOHYDo}HVHYLVWDVGRPRGHORHOHWU{QLFR $SUHVHQWDomRÀQDOGR$QWHSURMHWRFRPD atualização do site. 2.2.4. $WLYLGDGHVSUHYLVWDVDXODVSUHVHQFLDLV SDUDDSUHVHQWDomRGRFXUVRHLQVWUXo}HV HVSHFtÀFDV)yUXPSDUDRGHEDWH DVVtQFURQRGRVWHPDVJHUDLV&KDWVSDUD RGHEDWHVLQFU{QLFRHFRQMXQWRGHWHPDV HVSHFtÀFRVH9LGHRFRQIHUrQFLDSDUDDV WDUHIDVTXHHQYROYDPRFRPSDUWLOKDPHQWR de aplicativos e/ou possam ser
incrementadas com a troca audiovisual GHLQIRUPDo}HV
2.2.5.3ULQFLSDLVDSOLFDWLYRVDGRWDGRV 0RRGOHFRPRDPELHQWHGR$WHOLHU 9LUWXDOGH3URMHWR 7KH%UDLQSDUDDDQiOLVHGRSURJUDPDGR +RWHOHFRQVWUXomRGRRUJDQRJUDPD 3KRWRVKRSSDUDDHGLomRGDVLPDJHQV 0LFURVRIW2IÀFHSDUDDSURGXomR GHWH[WRVWDEHODVHDSUHVHQWDo}HV HOHWU{QLFDV $XWR&$'SDUDDPRGHODJHPGR ORFDOHGHVHQYROYLPHQWRGRSURMHWR $XWRGHVN$UFKLWHFWXUDO'HVNWRSSDUD %,0HFRRUGHQDomRDXWRPDWL]DGDGRV diversos documentos produzidos.
'6WXGLR²5HOHDVHSDUDDV UHQGHUL]Do}HVHDQLPDo}HV 'UHDP:HDYHUSDUDDHODERUDomRGRVLWH de apresentação do projeto. 2.2.6. &DUJDKRUiULDHQ~PHURGHDOXQRV 8PVHPHVWUHFRPTXLQ]HDXODVGHWUrV KRUDVXPDYH]SRUVHPDQD )RLDEHUWRHPDQWLGRXP)yUXPHQWUHDVDXODV SUHVHQFLDLVSDUDRGHEDWHSHUPDQHQWHH DVVtQFURQRGDVSULQFLSDLVTXHVW}HVOHYDQWDGDV pelas atividades programadas.
$OpPGLVVRUHDOL]DPRVXP&KDWTXHVHUHYHORX EDVWDQWHSURGXWLYRFRPWRGRVRVDOXQRV participando, a partir de pontos remotos, GXUDQWHRTXDOGLVFXWLPRVRVGDGRVOHYDQWDGRV por eles e enviados ao Fórum praticamente QR~OWLPRPRPHQWRFRQVHJXLQGRHVWDEHOHFHU DOJXPDVFRQFOXV}HVDUHVSHLWRGDYRFDomRHGDV SRVVLELOLGDGHVGRORWHSURSRVWR
3DUDHVVDILQDOLGDGHIRLXWLOL]DGRRDSOLFDWLYR 0LFURVRIW2IILFH3RZHU3RLQWEXVFDQGRH[SORUDU os recursos de multimídia e navegação através GHK\SHUOLQNVFRPRXPDIRUPDLQWURGXWyULD GRVUHFXUVRV+70/GHVDILRDVHUYHQFLGRQD etapa seguinte. $VDSUHVHQWDo}HVIRUDPUHDOL]DGDVHP DXODSUHVHQFLDOGHIRUPDDGLQDPL]DURV FRPHQWiULRVVREUHRVSURMHWRVDVHUHPIHLWRV SHORVSURIHVVRUHVHDOXQRVHDRPHVPRWHPSR UHVJDWDUDGLQkPLFDGRJUXSRQRVWHUPRVMi DOHUWDGRVSRU.YDQ&$$'5,$ $HVWUDWpJLDGHXFHUWRHRVUHVXOWDGRVIRUDPEHP DOpPGDH[SHFWDWLYDGRVSURIHVVRUHVFRPUHODomR jVSRVVLELOLGDGHVGRJUXSRDWpDTXHOHPRPHQWR )RLDEHUWRHQWmRXP)yUXPGHDSRLRDR GHVHQYROYLPHQWRGR(VWXGR3UHOLPLQDUHQTXDQWR DVDXODVSUHVHQFLDLVVHJXLQWHVGHGLFDUDPVH à instrumentalização dos alunos em relação à XWLOL]DomRGHGHWHUPLQDGDVIHUUDPHQWDVGLJLWDLV GHDSRLRDRSURMHWRGHDUTXLWHWXUDHDTXHODV voltadas para a apresentação digital interativa, EDVHDGDVQD,QWHUQHW
1HVWHPRPHQWRRJUXSRGHPRQVWURXXPD HQRUPHGLÀFXOGDGHGHDFRPSDQKDUR
FURQRJUDPDSUpHVWDEHOHFLGRHUDUDVYH]HVIH] XVRGR)yUXPSDUDFRORFDUTXHVW}HVVREUHR desenvolvimento do projeto, a ponto de sermos REULJDGRVDXQLÀFDUDVGXDV~OWLPDVHWDSDV adiando a entrega intermediária.
Figura 1: Página inicial do site de apresentação do Estudo Preliminar de uma das equipes.
3. Desenvolvimento do trabalho (PERUDSUHYLVWRSDUDXPDWXUPDGH TXLQ]HDOXQRVSRUUD]}HVGLYHUVDVRFXUVR GHVHQYROYHXVHFRPDSHQDVVHLVDOXQRV GHGLIHUHQWHVVHPHVWUHVFRPGRPtQLR FRQKHFLPHQWRHKDELOLGDGHGLVWLQWRVHPUHODomR ao uso da computação e o desenvolvimento de SURMHWRVGHDUTXLWHWXUD 2JUXSRIRLGLYLGLGRHPGXDVHTXLSHVSDUDD UHDOL]DomRGDVWDUHIDVSUHYLVWDVQRFURQRJUDPD e, em conjunto, realizamos aulas presenciais para apresentação do curso e para a explicação GRVFRQFHLWRVEiVLFRVTXHSHUPHLDPXP$WHOLHU Virtual de Projeto, como a idéia de comunicação jGLVWkQFLDVLQFU{QLFDRXDVVtQFURQDHD correlação desses conceitos com as atividades XVXDLVGHXPDWHOLHUWUDGLFLRQDOHLQVWUXomRVREUH RVUHFXUVRVRIHUHFLGRVSHORVDSOLFDWLYRVDGRWDGRV
Figura 2: Página inicial do site de apresentação do Estudo Preliminar da outra equipe.
&RQVLGHUDo}HVÀQDLV (PUHÁHWLQGRVREUHDVHQWmRUHFHQWHV H[SHULrQFLDVGH9'67KRPDV.YDQHVWDEHOHFHX uma comparação entre o Atelier Virtual e o Atelier Tradicional demonstrando as diversas GLÀFXOGDGHVGHVVDSURSRVWDTXHWHQWDWUDEDOKDU didaticamente a prática projetual através de DWLYLGDGHVQmRSUHVHQFLDLVHjGLVWkQFLD %DVLFDPHQWHFRPR.YDQGHPRQVWURXDPDLRU
GLÀFXOGDGHGR$WHOLHU9LUWXDOGH3URMHWRVp MXVWDPHQWHDTXHVHUHIHUHjVXEVWLWXLomRGR PHLRDPELHQWHUHDOHSURIXVDPHQWHLQWHUDWLYR onde acontece o Atelier Tradicional, por um DPELHQWHRQGHRVSURFHVVRVGHFRPXQLFDomRVH WRUQDPPXLWRPDLVOLPLWDGRV.YDQS
Segundo ele, no Atelier Tradicional o aluno DSUHVHQWDRVHXWUDEDOKRSDUDRSURIHVVRUHDOpP GHRXYLURVFRPHQWiULRVSRGHYrORHWDPEpP DVVXDVH[SUHVV}HVVHXVWUDoRVHDVXDOLQJXDJHP FRUSRUDOTXHHQIDWL]DPGHWHUPLQDGRVDVSHFWRV da proposta apresentada. Além disso, o aluno YrHSRGHVHUYLVWRSHORVRXWURVFROHJDVTXH GHVVHPRGRWDPEpPDSUHQGHPSDUWLFLSDQGR indiretamente do atendimento de cada um.
2TXHWDPEpPDFRQWHFHQRPRPHQWRGD DSUHVHQWDomRÀQDOGRVWUDEDOKRVSDUDXPD EDQFDGHSURIHVVRUHVTXHID]HPFRPHQWiULRV e, eventualmente, discordam entre si, SURSRUFLRQDQGRDRVHVWXGDQWHVXPDPELHQWHGH DSUHQGL]DGRGLQkPLFRTXHRIHUHFHGLIHUHQWHV DERUGDJHQVSRVVtYHLVSDUDXPPHVPRSUREOHPD
Desse modo, concluiu Kvan, além dos alunos DEVRUYHUHPXPDHQRUPHTXDQWLGDGHGH LQIRUPDo}HVDRPHVPRWHPSRHOHVDFDEDP VHQGRHVWLPXODGRVDSURGX]LUHPPDLVHPHOKRU em relação à produção geral do grupo. (VWHpSRUWDQWRRHQRUPHGHVDÀRDVHUYHQFLGR
inicialmente por um Atelier Virtual de Projetos onde os participantes atuam isoladamente HjGLVWkQFLDWHQGRFRPRPHLRFRPXQLFDomR exclusivamente os recursos proporcionados por VHXFRPSXWDGRUHUHVSHFWLYRVDSOLFDWLYRVHTXH SRUWDQWRUHTXHUXPDSRVWXUDGLIHUHQFLDGD PXLWRPDLVHQJDMDGDHSUyDWLYDGRTXH normalmente costuma ocorrer no cotidiano de nossas escolas. 1HVWHVHQWLGRUHODWRVPDLVUHFHQWHVGHWHQWDWLYDV
de realização de um Atelier Virtual de Projetos HPQRVVRSDtV²FRPRRWUDEDOKRDSUHVHQWDGRQR congresso anual da SIGraDi em 2004 (Santos e Kós, GHPRQVWUDPTXHQmRVHSRGHVXEHVWLPDU HVVDVGLÀFXOGDGHVGHVGHDGHÀQLomRGRHVFRSR GRWUDEDOKRHVXDUHVSHFWLYDPHWRGRORJLDDWp DVHWDSDVGHDYDOLDomRSDVVDQGRSHODHVFROKD GDHTXLSHGHDOXQRVHDGHÀQLomRGRVUHFXUVRV tecnológicos a serem utilizados.
(IRLH[DWDPHQWHRTXHFRQVWDWDPRVHPQRVVD SUySULDH[SHULrQFLDTXHSDVVRXSRUDOWRVH EDL[RVQRGHVHPSHQKRGRJUXSRFRQIRUPHDV GLIHUHQWHVDWLYLGDGHVSURSRVWDV
$PDLRULDGRVHVWXGDQWHVPDQWHYHVHDSiWLFD em relação à utilização do Fórum, deixando de responder às mensagens diárias enviadas pelo VLVWHPDHFRPRHPTXDOTXHUGLVFLSOLQDUHJXODU GHL[DQGRSDUDD~OWLPDKRUDRHQYLRGRPDWHULDO GHSHVTXLVDVROLFLWDGRFRPGXDVVHPDQDVGH DQWHFHGrQFLDLQGLFDQGRDtTXHDVLPSOHV adoção de novas tecnologias não determina, SRUFRQVHTrQFLDLPHGLDWDHLQVWDQWkQHDXPD mudança comportamental.
1RH[WUHPRRSRVWRWRGDYLDRFRUUHXD SDUWLFLSDomRQR&KDWTXHIRLHQWXVLDVPDGD HHQYROYHXSUDWLFDPHQWHRJUXSRWRGR1HVWD atividade, os alunos demonstraram o domínio, TXHGHIDWRWrPGHVVDIRUPDGHFRPXQLFDomR VLQFU{QLFDEDVHDGRVpFODURQXPDSUiWLFDGLiULD TXHUHDOL]DPHQWUHVLHVSRQWDQHDPHQWHDWUDYpV GR061%ORJV)ORJVHDÀP 1RHQWDQWRUHYHODUDPWDPEpPXPDHQRUPH LQFDSDFLGDGHGHHQFDPLQKDUXPSHQVDPHQWR IRFDQGRXP~QLFRWySLFRHHVJRWDQGRRWHPD depois de realizada uma rodada inteira entre os SDUWLFLSDQWHVSDUDTXHWRGRVHFDGDXPSXGHVVHP H[SUHVVDUVXDVRSLQL}HV$VLGpLDVÁXtUDPGH PDQHLUDFDyWLFDHDPXLWRFXVWRIRUDPVHQGR RUGHQDGDVSHORVSURIHVVRUHVGDGLVFLSOLQDTXH DWXDUDPFRPR0HGLDGRUHV²XPDÀJXUDDOLiV indispensável numa atividade deste tipo. 7DPEpPVHPRVWURXHÀFD]DUHDOL]DomRGDV aulas semanais presenciais, dedicadas à
LQVWUXPHQWDOL]DomRGRVDOXQRVGDPHVPDIRUPD TXHDDSUHVHQWDomRSUHVHQFLDOGR3DUWLGRTXH resgatou para o grupo, num momento de crise, a SRVVLELOLGDGHGHLQWHUDomRQRVPROGHVSRQWXDGRV SRU7KRPDV.YDQ
Além disso, a necessidade de se aprender novos FRQWH~GRVLQVWUXPHQWDLVFRPROLGDUFRPQRYRV DSOLFDWLYRV²RDPELHQWH0RRGOH7KH%UDLQ 'UHDPZHDYHUHWF²RXUHFXUVRVGRWLSR6SDFH 3ODQQLQJ0DVV(OHPHQWV;UHIVHWFRIHUHFLGRV SHOR$XWRFDG$'7DRPHVPRWHPSRHPTXHVH EXVFDYDHODERUDURSURMHWRDUTXLWHW{QLFRSDUHFH WHUVLGRH[FHVVLYRFRQÀUPDQGRDQHFHVVLGDGH GHXPDIDVHSUHSDUDWyULDDQWHULRUQDTXDOHVWDV TXHVW}HVLQVWUXPHQWDLVIRVVHPUHVROYLGDV (PTXHSHVHWRGDYLDDVGLÀFXOGDGHVMi UHODWDGDVDH[SHULrQFLDIRLLPSRUWDQWHHVHUYLUi FRPRVXEVtGLRDRDSHUIHLoRDPHQWRGDGLVFLSOLQD SURSRVWDTXHVHSUHWHQGHVHMDFRQVROLGDGDFRPR XPDRSomRDVHURIHUHFLGDDFDGDVHPHVWUH
Agradecimentos $FDGrPLFRVTXHSDUWLFLSDPGR$WHOLHU9LUWXDOGH 3URMHWR² &DPLOD%HYLODFTXDGH7ROHGR&LQWLD+LGHPL .XUDRND*DEULHOD3DXORQ-XOLDQD$\URVD5LQDOGL 5REHUWD7LDJR0DFHGR0HOOR Referências %5$')25'-:&+(1*1DQG.9$17KRPDV 7KH9LUWXDO6WXGLR,Q&RPSXWHU$LGHG $UFKLWHFWXUDO'HVLJQWK(XURSHDQ&RQIHUHQFH RQ(GXFDWLRQ3URFHHGLQJVSS*ODVJRZ 6FRWODQG6HSWHPEHU .2/$5(9,&%UDQNRHWDO$QH[SHULPHQWLQ 'HVLJQ&RODERUDWLRQ,Q'LJLWDO'HVLJQ6WXGLRV 'RFRPSXWHUVPDNHDGLIIHUHQFH"²$FDGLD· 3URFHHGLQJVSS4XpEHF .Ð6-RVp5LSSHU$RUJDQL]DomRGR´+DELWDUD FLGDGHµRH[DPHGHXPH[HUFtFLRGHSURMHWR FRODERUDWLYR,Q26HQWLGRHR8QLYHUVR'LJLWDO ²9,,,&RQJUHVVR,EHUR$PHULFDQRGH*UiÀFD 'LJLWDO3URFHHGLQJVSS8QLVLQRV6mR Leopoldo, 2004. .9$17KRPDV²6WXGLR7HFKLQJZLWKRXWPHHWLQJ SHGDJRJLFDODVSHFWVRID9LUWXDO'HVLJQ6WXGLR ,Q7KH6HFRQG&RQIHUHQFHRQ&RPSXWHU$LGHG $UFKLWHFWXUDO'HVLJQLQ$VLD²&DDGULD· 3URFHHGLQJVSS7DLZDQ 1$5'(//,(GXDUGR6DPSDLR*UiÀFDGLJLWDO DSOLFDGDjDUTXLWHWXUDGDIRUPDomRDWXDODR IXWXURGHVXDDSOLFDomR,Q9LVmRH9LVXDOL]DomR ²,;&RQJUHVVR,EHURDPHULFDQRGH*UiÀFD 'LJLWDO3URFHHGLQJVSS8QLYHUVLGDGH 3HUXDQDGH&LrQFLDV$SOLFDGDV/LPD 6$1726(GXDUGR0DVFDUHQKDV²$GLVFLSOLQD KDELWDUDFLGDGHHRFRQFHLWRGHDWHOLrYLUWXDO GHSURMHWR,Q26HQWLGRHR8QLYHUVR'LJLWDO ²9,,,&RQJUHVVR,EHUR$PHULFDQRGH*UiÀFD 'LJLWDO3URFHHGLQJVSS8QLVLQRV6mR Leopoldo, 2004. 9,1&(17&KDUOHV&3URMHWR$UTXLWHW{QLFRH &RPSXWDomR*UiÀFD3URFHVVRV0pWRGRVH(QVLQR ,Q26HQWLGRHR8QLYHUVR'LJLWDO²9,,,&RQJUHVVR ,EHUR$PHULFDQRGH*UiÀFD'LJLWDO3URFHHGLQJV SS8QLVLQRV6mR/HRSROGR KWWSPRRGOHRUJDFHVVRHP KWWSHDGPDFNHQ]LHFRPEUPRRGOHDFHVVR HP KWWSHDGPDFNHQ]LHFRPEUPRRGOHFRXUVH YLHZSKS"LG ²DFHVVRHP KWWSSURIHVVRUPDFNHQ]LHFRPEUWDOOHU²DFHVVR HP KWWSDUFKRQHWDPXHGX(JYYBIDFHVVR HP